as regards their "kulturfähigkeit"; and, finally, that even if we accept the hypothesis, the likeness between these primevals and their present-day descendants consists only in name. Apart from certain types in Pomerania and Scandinavia, the modern German is (physically) a mixture of all manner of peoples.
All this, however, is only a small part of the criticism which an impartial study of the matter leads one to level against the whole structure, and bring it down like a pack of cards. It cannot stand against serious criticism; but it was necessary to give a cursory survey of the facts, since we are engaged not only in the negative task of destroying existing theories, but in the positive one of establishing a true test of race value in general, and of the cultural value of the Jewish race in particular.
It follows, if we look at the question from this point of view, that we shall arrive at a fundamentally different verdict as to the race value of the Jews; and that anti-Jewish politics, deprived of their scientific basis, have no ground to stand on. But this is only in appearance.
The Jews, with all their cleverness and agility, do not, after all, produce the highest genius.Their intellectual activity is limited to combinations of existing elements. Intuitive perception in the sphere of human speculation, the artist's vision which creates masterpieces, these are lacking in the Jew of the present day, however highly educated he may be! It is the Germans, the English, the French, and the Italians of the end of the Middle Ages who sowed the fertile seeds, the harvest of which we reap to-day in the fresh rejuvenating impulses in art, philosophy, and science; in political and social life—all of which are propagated certainly with zest by the Jews, at any rate in those countries in which they are numerous. However we may choose to explain this in the past by the repression of the Jews, a frank view of the situation to-day shows us that there must be distinctive and fundamental psychological reasons for it. How else are we to account for these glaring facts which immediately rush to the mind?
And this brings us into the province of the philosophy of history.
While our discussion has so far been anthropological, we come now to the much
more difficult task of determining the race value of a people, where one is so liable to go on mistaken premises. We have to deal here both with the fundamental mistakes contained in present and past conceptions of history, and with the fundamental error upon which the present biological theory is based. It is to these two cardinal errors that we owe the contradictory opinions on the subject of race which we have tried to set out above.
This fundamental error is the notion of the permanence of race-character which is, emphasized as though it were a law. Since it applies to the zoological and botanical classes, species and kinds, it is supposed that it applies also to human races. But so far as the subject has any relation to our theme, we are concerned much less with morphological and physiological than with purely psychological characteristics. If the race-question is to enter seriously into political economy, and starts out from the standpoint, which may be well-founded and hypothetical, that the ethnical units have equal social and cultural values, the correctness of this standpoint with all its consequences must depend on the correctness of the general proposition, whether these ethnical values remain constant, or whether in the course of a certain period they nay not be transformed into their exact opposite, In that latter case all political consequences, so far as they claim a higher sanction, utterly fall to the ground. But independently of the political consequences, it is indespensable for our understanding of the histurical process to ascertain clearly whether constant erganic biological hereditary values. in the sense of specifically recurring race-psychologies, are the moving forces of the Iistory of culture, whether with greater justice the race-factor can be neglected and the materialistic conception of history can be introduced to explain the movement, or hnally whether in place of these conflicting theories of which neither can entirely explain the facts, a synthetic formula can he set up which is in no point opposed to the facts, and which at the same time might be the basis of political programmes that would have the advantage of corresponding in a much higher degree with the ideals of humanity, of progress, and the welfare of vast masses.
We must here make a big leap and sum-
