The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 8 · February 1912
209printed page
scan 5 of 30
THE MACCABAEAN
209

of these wonderful men brought to my memory the Talmudic saying:

"Alas, that lost to us are men Whom we cannot find again." (Sahedrin III.)

Before closing my reflections about Mikvei Yisrael, I feel that I have not do justice to the subject who indirectly or indirectly of the school, who reacted with the maturation of Palestine which preceded Zion- to such names as Kalischer, Moses Hess, and John Grætz.

Early in the "1860, Rabbi Kalischer of Thorn and Ra i Gutmacher advocated the Colonization of Palestine by Jews from a religious-national point of view. They were the pioneers of practical Zionism. Kalischer carried on a great agitation for the idea of Colonizing Palestine and cultivating its land. He urged the Jew to establish a school to teach Jewish youths the art and science of farming, and he advocated the placing in Palestine of a Jewish military guard for the protection of Jewish settlers. In his book “Derisath Zion” (Lyck, 1862), he makes it plain that the redemption of the Jews as promised by the Prophets could only be accomplished in a gradual and natural way and only through endeavor and self-help on the part of the Jews. He traveled extensively to propagate his doctrine. He addressed meetings, influenced many prominent rabbis to join the movement, and he created a public opinion in Germany and elsewhere. He was instrumental in organizing the first Palestine Colonization Society in Frankfort-on-the-Main in 1861. His letter to Albert Cohen of Paris will always remain one of the most valuable documents in the archives of the Jewish National Movement. (1)

Moses Hess, called “the Communist Rabbi,” was the first scientific exponent in modern times of a Jewish state. His “Rome and Jerusalem” (1862) will always

(1) See Kol Zophaim, Hamburg, 1867.

remain the basic work of Zionist literature. The leading ideas in “Rome and Jerusa- salem” are “The Jews will always remain foreigners among other people. They emancipate them for humanitarian reasons, but will never respect them so long as the Jews place their own historical memories in the background, and hold to the principle of “Ube bene ibi patria.” * * * "The Jewish type is indestructible, and the national feeling of the Jew cannot be uprooted, in spite of the German Jews, who, for the sake of more liberty and hope for perfect equality have persuaded themselves of the contrary” * * * “If Jewish emancipation in other lands is incompatible with Jewish nationalism, emancipation must give way to nationality.” (2) Hess had probably some influence on Grætz who came out with an essay in the “Jahrbuch Fur Israeliten” (1863 p. 64.) “Die Verjungung des Judischer Stammes,” where he corroborates by historical facts that the Jewish nation is its own Messiah and must be its own rejuvinator if it wishes to be redeemed. These brilliant rabbis and scholars, who, by words of mouth and pen, brought the question of Colonization of Palestine to the front, have influenced the Alliance Israelite Universelle to take action in the matter, and consequently in the year 1868 Charles Netter was sent to Palestine to investigate the condition of the land, and the advisability of taking up Jewish Colonization there. Mr. Netter, on his return to Paris advised the Alliance organization to open a school for training Jewish youths of Palestine and other Oriental countries in agricultural pursuits, In spite of a minority who argued that the Jew is not adaptable to farming and will not succeed by tilling the soil, the organization accepted the recommendation of Mr. Netter, who returned to Palestine soon after and obtained concessions from the Turkish government to open the school. By way of encouragement, the Turkish government presented to the “Alliance” a large tract of land in the vicinity of Jaffa, In 1870 the school Mikvei Yisrael was established on the government land by the energetic efforts of Charles Netter.

(2) See "Rome and Jerusalem" the Lette Nationalitat Frage.