The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 8 · February 1912
222printed page
scan 18 of 30
Facsimile · scan 18 of 30
Scan of p. 222
Text · transcribed from the scan

EDITORIAL

DR. MAGNES MOVES FORWARD.

Tue New York Jewish Community is to be congratulated upon the success of Dr. Magnes in securing a fund of over $300,000 for the purpose of Jewish education. <A serious attempt is to be made to establish order in the affairs of the metropolis, where, according to the latest authority, there ara ahant anne millinn Tewe

But above all Dr. Magnes himself is to be congratulated. He has freed himself from all rabbinical obligation and henceforth stands out in American Jewish life as a secular leader, whose sole object is the strengthening and upbuilding of Jewish life in the Dispersion; Jewish life, that is, not limited by the interests of religion in its narrow sense.

It is concluded by persons who are the observers of the superficial, that Dr. Magnes has made a failure of his rabbinical career. They say that he has been the rabbi of three successive congregations, from which he has withdrawn, confessing his failure to effect those theological or religious changes, upon which he had set his heart.

The fact is that Dr. Magnes is much larger than any of the petty tasks which he set before himself, when he came to New York as a rabbi. He is not the type of the rabbi, theologically equipped to fight the progressive wing, and he himself is not an adherent of the brand of orthodoxy with which, unfortunately for his enterprises, he sught to connect himself. Dr. Magnes is a secular leader, whose influence is effective in the direction of building up Jewish life in general, which is much larger than Judaism, and from his point of view, much more important. Into Jewish secular life, as it were, Dr. Magnes has brought, the spirit of candor, of dignity, and of enlightened progress.

He has thus became a leader of much greater rinfluence. Henceforth he will not be called upon to justify this or that action by any theological rule.

He does not represent the reform or the orthodox or the counter-reform wing of

Judaism. He stands more firmly on the Zionist platform, which recognizes as valuable the positive, strengthening influences in all shades of Jewish religious opinion, and sets its face only against such religious manifestations that deny the future of the Jewish nation and the value of the potency of Jewish national traditions.

We have always felt that as a Zionist, Dr. Magnes should have made the center of all his endeavors the Zionist movement, working out from it upon Jewish life. Dr. Magnes himself, a child of his people, subject to the varying influences of the Jewish life by which he was surrounded, evidently thought that he could best promote Zionism by going out of the movement, and, by exercising the native Zionist sentiment with which his spirit is impregnated, bring into our movement forces and influences he could not otherwise reach. This policy may have been wrong. It is a subject which involves a great deal. But that Dr. Magnes has been true to his own ideals, has followed the light of his own being, and that he has been successful in keeping that light burning clearly and steadily before him, cannot be doubted by those who know him.

We hope for the time when he will become strong enough in the influence that he wields to align himself completely in all that he does with the Zionist movement.

THE FRENCH ALLIANCE.

The Alliance Universelle Israelite, whose original name, Kol Israel Habarim, has become meaningless, is determined to perpetuate its present reactionary administration at the expense, it seems, of its history and its value in the Jewish camp. It has abolished its German branch, and will deal with its foreign members direct from Paris, where Bigart is in command, and where the influence of Salomon Reinach is still effective.

With its center in republican France, it has cast its lot with Bourbonism and autocracy. It has set its face against democ-