The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 8 · February 1912
215printed page
scan 11 of 30

Whereas the growth and expression of inner cualities finds favorable opportunities among peoples still attached to their soil, because of the stability of wealth and means and of leisure to think and reflect on self-expression, 0 the other hand, an artificially created class of traders, among whom political and economic conditions raise the struggle for existence to the highest pitch, must leave these higher qualities and capacities to lie fallow and rusting. Cunning and unscrupulousness already offer more prospect of success in daily competition than do character and harmonious education. The teleology, the purposefulness which Wer-, ner Sombart takes to be a fundamental characteristic of the Jewish race, is to be referred to this anti-sclective effect. To this must be added the consideration that the dissolution of the old religious an:l Ghetto environments, in which men were still something whole and complete after their own kind, has brought into being a void and hollow generation of people in transition. The indeterminate and inwardly vacillating character of these persons in transition, since it often distinguishes the successful Jews of the modern world, gave the incentive for regarding such peculiarities as the fundamental characteristics of the whole Jewish race. It is, perhaps, an irreparable injury that in consequence of the artificial esteem of superficiality and of false spiritual values, just the nobler personalities fell! back on themselves and did not come to the front. To-day, and for the great part. only the striving, cunning, middling. pushing Jews are known, and the whole of Jewry 8 judged from: them! This grossly -deceptive portrayal, the inevitable consequence of the sociological structure of the Jews of the Diaspora, brought it about that the Jews as a body were regarded as the anti-type of all higher human worth.

ven in respect of purely mental development, the circumstances of selection are altogether different among Jews. Among Christians in Germany only one boy in twenty, as a rule, enters the higher schools, and so the process of selection already plays its part in the home. Parents give the advantages of higher education only to the most highly endowed children. The Jews, on the other hand, try to provide every child with higher

schooling. Among them, attendance at a higher school is not the exception, but the rule. The consequence of the absence of selection is, that many weakly endowed go to the colleges and universities and lower the general intellectual standard. These weakly endowed children do indeed attain thir academic degree, but remain average people throughout their lives. The higher percentage of talented persons as compared with Christians, and the relatively much rarer appearance of the especially high quality of genius, thus shows itself to be the natural consequence of this hot-honce colture

The peculiar conditions, then, make existing circumstances inevitable. The Jews under existing conditions cannot possibly attain the degree of fruitful activity which their forefathers attained in far antiquity and later in Spain, when they were the initiators of those cultural epochs which gave to Europe the content of its spiritual life. None the less, even under existing conditions, as Sombart has cited authorities to show, the Jews have created the whole modern capitalist development. Their ability made America what it is to-day, The wealth of Holland, of Frankfort, of Hamburg, of London is due to them. Since their emancipation they have exercised a fructifying influence in every sphere over the whole of Europe. In purely spiritual spheres of activity they are not only collaborators, but also largely creators of new tendencies now dominating science: To name only a few there are Hertz, Ehrlich, Marx, Stahl, Spinoza, etc. There are the Jewish discoveries in the fields of locomotion which so characterize the age—the automobile, the dirigible airship. The profundity of Jewish thinkers has influenced changes in spiritual, ethical, and religious worths, and revolutionized the whole spiritual life. This record should have enlightened us concerning the value of Jews for culture under healthy conditions. That we have not drawn the obvious conclusion can only be due to the fear of its sounding dithyrambic.

The Jewish people is now engaged in a struggle not only with the world around it, but also within itself; two diverse tendencies being manifested, from which the continuance or the end of the race must ultimately depend. Besides the struggle