The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 7 · January 1912
195printed page
scan 19 of 30
THE MACCABAEAN
195

have been unable to kindle the inspiration which is so much needed.

It is to be hoped that Dr. Mossinsohn will secure the funds for the Hebrew Gymnasium, for which he came. But it is to be hoped the more that every Zionist who comes in contact with him will have the eyes to see, and the soul to feel, in him the exponent of the New Jewish Citizen, who is without guile and without fear.

MR. DE HAAS'S VIEWS.

We have the highest regard for Mr. Jacob de Haas as a Zionist, and as an able observer of Jewish events. His devotion to the movement dates back to its genesis, when he served Theodor Herzl with unqualified devotion and loyalty. During the past few years, however, he has had the idea fixed in his mind that the policies for which Herzl gave his life have been reversed by his successors, and that in effect the political ideal of Zionism had been supplanted by what was known at the time Herzl entered the Jewish world world of affairs as klein-colonization, or Chovevei Zionism.

In the article which Mr. de Haas con- tribtttes to this issue of The Waccabaran he sets forth what he thinks is an opportunity for the reassertion of political Zionism, but he gives expression to his idea in a tone which, we submit, is not conducive to an appreciation of tis merits. 116 assumes, first of all, that his suggestion will not find favor with the present leaders of our movement in Europe. and feels that he has made his last attempt to bring a misguided movement back to its original bearings.

That the movement, since Herz!'s passing away, has ever heen ready to utilize a political situation for the furtherance of our ideal, cannot be doubted by an unbiased observer. The trouble has been not with their unwillingness to move. but with their inability to take the step. A test of the actual strength of the movement in the acquisition of the docking rights to Jaffa and Haifa would reveal the fact that We at the present time are tinable to mass

the required funds to start negotiations. Herzl's views regarding the charter had in them the element of daring adventure and speculation. He played the game like a master, but what would have happened had the other side called him, as it were? There would have been a colossal catastrophe, and Zionism would have suffered a reverse which would have made impossible any further endeavor.

It is of course possible that with a man of Herzl's genius, a way out of the dilemma would have been found, but we of today have come to realize that our movement has no right to risk even a splendid failure. We are prepared to bring any sacrifice, to risk our individual future for the sake of the future of the nation, but to risk the future of the movement itself is something that no man dare undertake.

The fact of the matter is that in spite of what Mr. de Haas may say, it is our firm conviction that the men now at the head of our movement appreciate the significance of political methods as well as did their predecessors; they are, however, men of sober mind, feeling the large responsibility that rests upon them. They see in the present work in Palestine not a fact of colonization, but a political fact, and they are determined that in spite of the risks, in spite of the waiting required, the infiltration of Jewish forces into Palestine is as vital and as imposing a political demonstration as the purchase of a charter would have been, had Herzl succeeded in his splendid endeavors.

It is idle, in our opinion, to speak of a political movement which has but one or two arrows in its quiver. The fact is that Zionism has become saturated with its essential political ideal, and that although the penetration of Palestine may not be qualified at every step with the label of political significance, every individual engaged in that work understands fully its political implications.

Let us rather cease harping on the shib- holeths, and come down to the realities of life.