The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 6 · December 1911
172printed page
scan 24 of 30
172
THE MACCABAEAN

thority which can legally and morally grant autonomy to Palestine. By what right or sense of logic can any politician or diplomat demand of the Turkish Parliament permission for the Jews to establish an autonomous nationality in Palestine when thereby they would be handing over 4-5th of the population to the sway of one-fifth? Supposing for argument's sake such a request were made and granted, would that grant be worth the paper it was written on? Would the Palestinian population stand for it?

You might say that by some inducement the Turkish Parliament might promise our Political Zionists that when Jews became the majority in Palestine they would grant them autonomy, but such a demand apart from its uselessness is undemocratic and immoral and inasmuch as we have always been the greatest sufferers from misrule by despots and cliques we would never endeavor to impose the rule of any nationality over any country without the consent of a majority of its residents. I can understand a demand of autonomy for all residents of Palestine but not for Jews or any other distinct nationality.

I may be mistaken both in my political and moral convictions and therefore ask for enlightenment.

The question of how we propose to acquire a publicly legally secured home for the Jewish people in Palestine is put to us daily and we cannot shelter ourselves under the plea that diplomacy cannot reveal its hand as we are playing an open diplomacy. We are telling the entire world our wants and aims. We must get followers in every clime and consequently cannot hide our methods which must be open and have criticism. Of course you or some of your readers might rightly ask how do the so-called "practical Zionists" propose to establish a publicly legally secured home for the Jewish people in Palestine? and without for a moment attempting to outline the official programme I will endeavor to show how I picture to myself The Way to Get There.

(1). Official Zionism should make it its business first and foremost to study the economic possibilities of Palestine and apply itself to solve the problem of the Jewish paupers to which class belongs over half of the Jewish population there.

(2). Educate the Jews to become Ottoman subjects and make such a step possible by eliminating the present disadvantage of Ottoman citizenship. The great drawback at present is that Justice sometimes miscarries in case of Ottoman citizens which is impossible with foreigners who are under the protection of their respective Consuls. As Turkey is a Constitutional country and its code of law is European, Justice can be had by appealing from the local decision. This is costly and therefore impossible to the poor Ottoman subject. This great drawback can be remedied by instituting say a Council of Lawyers whose duty it would be to appeal and fight any misdecision to the Highest Court of Appeal.

(3). When sufficient Jews have been converted from paupers into desirable citizens, teach them to use the franchise and agitate legally for the abolition on the Red Ticket.

(4). Encourage the speaking of Hebrew as the common language of our people by looking diligently after the education of the children.

(5). Make it possible for Jews from abroad to imigrate to Palestine by giving them the best information and showing how a livelihood can be had there. Encourage such an influx by the formation of Achoozos.

(6). When there are sufficient Jews there to make the word Palestine synonymous with Jews, like Ireland with Irish, Poland with Poles, Finland with Finn's, etc., demand Home Rule for Palestine.

You might argue that the Jews in Palestine would by then be assimiliated like their western brethren. This I believe is just as impossible as assimilation was in the middle ages. The Jews in Palestine live in their own quarters, speak their own language, enjoy even now a measure of home rule and are quite distinct from the rest of the population.

The Turkish Government can have no objection to the above action as every step taken is of advantage to the entire Empire.

I am with Zion's greetings,Yours very sincerely,SIMON GOLDMAN,St. Louis, Mo.,2921 Locust St.