The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 6 · December 1911
167printed page
scan 19 of 30
Facsimile · scan 19 of 30
Scan of p. 167
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE COMING OF MOSSINSOHN.

We welcome the advent of Dr. Ben Zion Mossinsohn, of Jaffa, who comes to New York the early part of January in the interests of Hebrew education in Palestine. We do this not so much because his oratorical ability will be placed in the service of the Federation of American Zionists, but also because his presence here will, we believe, clear the ground of the criticism which has been levelled against the Hebrew Gymnasium where he teaches. A great deal has been said in opposition to the Gymnasium, and most of it by Zionists with a bitterness of spirit not at all commendable. With Dr. Mossinsohn here, we shall be able to learn the truth, and be enabled to judge for ourselves whether the critics have been fair toward the institution.

MR. GOLDMAN'S CRITICISM.

MR. SIMON GOLDMAN is a Zionist of whose work nothing but praise can be said, and we are therefore reluctant to enter into a discussion on the points he makes in his letter, which is printed in this issue. It is incumbent upon us, however, in justice to ourselves to reply to what we consider his unfair argument against our editorial of last month.

Mr. Goldman wholly misunderstands our position and confuses the issue by imputing to us every thing that he says concerning political Zionism. We have no quarrel with his method of attaining the Zionist goal, but we have a right to ask of him that he should not outline our methods and then proceed, of his own accord, to demolish the method he attributes to us.

We are not of those Zionists who demand that nothing shall be done in Palestine until guarantee has been given to the Zionists of an autonomous state. Nor do we believe that this is the thought of any of the so-called political Zionists. What we have said, and we repeat it, is that the leading motive of all our work in Palestine must be political, in the sense that ahead of every practical piece of work there shall be the guiding national

mind to steer its course in the right path. It is not only in number that our strength lies. It is not only in the aggregation of individuals that we receive our assurance of the future of the Jewish nation. An individual who goes to Palestine may be a Jew and yet an assimilationist. He may desire the right to live in Palestine and may repudiate the Jewish national language, the Jewish national culture; he may be, in other words, merely of the Jewish persuasion and an Arabian in culture, or a Turk in culture and aspiration.

We claim that men like Mr. Gildman are so zealous in their advocacy of immediate work in Palestine that they forget that the movement is a national one that looks not so much upon the success of national enterprises in Palestine, as for the successful implanting of the Jewish national spirit in Palestine.

We rejoice with every true Zionist in the nationally-inspired Zionist work that is being done in Palestine. Every dunam of land wrested from aliens in Zion strengthens our position there. Every man added to the population, provided he is imbued with national ideals, gives us cause for congratulation. But we should be blind to the best interests of our movement did we not insist that the light and leading for all this endeavor must come from men who see this work as part of the building of a Jewish nation on its own soil.

The Federation of American Zionists has had printed INSTALLMENT SHARE-BOOKS, providing for the purchase on the installment plan of shares for the Jewish Colonial Trust, the Anglo-Palestine Company, the Palestine Land Development Company and the Dunams of Land. These share-books may be obtained from the Federation office, 230 Grand street, at $1.00 A VOLUME. It is urged upon all societies to avail themselves of this method of purchasing shares in the companies named, and to appoint the proper committees. The Federation has in preparation a special Circular describing the various institutions, which will be issued soon.