The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 5 · November 1911
142printed page
scan 24 of 32
142
THE MACCABAEAN

in few, the (if you please) "practical" work of Jewish settlement upon the ancestral soil was prosecuted, for a time, with some vigor.

In the midst of this, there happened a rare and momentous event, namely, a master-mind threw himself with all his power athwart the Jewish problem. At once, the pottering of sentimentalists and philanthropists in Palestine received its proper setting. The settlement of Jews in Palestine was good, if and when such settlement contributed to a statesman's solution of the whole Jewish question. But even Herzl himself did not at first grasp the totality of that question, which is two-folds, material and spiritual. To rescue the Jewish people from persecution is the one-half of the problem; the answer of the Zionists to this Jewish question is contained in a single word: renationalization.

At autonomous Jewish people is the ideal of Zionism. Upon the basis of autonomy, we Zionists believe, the Jewish spirit will be recollected, recomposed, so that it may become potent again, as of yore, in the service of civilization.

Sir, the soul is greater than the soil, and the ideal of Zionism is dearer to me than Zion itself. Were Palestine impossible for us, there would be no cause—nay, it would be a betrayal of our ideal—to despair. As the Puritans founded a New England, from whose flourishing metropolis I send you this letter, so, if need be, we Zionists could found, somewhere on God's earth, a New Palestine.

But Providence is very kind. Old Palestine, the land of our sires, is open to our enterprise. I am a Palestinian Zionist, not because I am for Palestine or nowhere, but because Palestine is at once, happily, the most welcome and the most welcoming land to us Zionists. Of this, we have a standing witness in the I. T. O.

So far, I have been led by the wish to expose the first cause of the present gratuitous distinction between "political" and "practical" Zionism. That cause is the lingering spirit of the defunct Chovevi Zion movement, complicated with the motive of philanthropy. I come now to the second factor in the confusion, namely, the question of a Charter.

Everyone knows that Herzl, to carry out the Zionist purpose, sought a charter

for Palestine from the Sultan of Turkey. Observe, the charter was to be but a means to an end, a method of procedure. The end was defined in the Basle Program, adopted at the first Zionist Congress, held in August, 1897. "Zionism aims to establish for the Jewish people a publicly, legally assured home in Palestine." Now, since the death of Herzl, the political situation in the Ottoman Empire has so changed that the method of prosecuting the Basle Program must needs change as well. Professor Gottheil has recently stated: "Herzl himself would have been the first to welcome such a change." Does this mean that political Zionism is dead? To think so would be to gloss over the elementary distinction between end and means, purpose and procedure. Our purpose, our end, our ideal, is found to-day, as definitively as fourteen years ago, within the four corners of the Basle Program. I agree absolutely with Professor Gottheil: "Herzlian Zionism is no more dead than Zionism itself, and when Herzlian Zionism dies, our movement, too, will be dead." That the Zionist organization has been able, without a grave crisis, to adapt itself to the changed situation, is an evidence of the extraordinary vigor of our movement.

I think we may now lay down, categorically, two obvious, but none the less illuminating, propositions. First: we can be "practical" Zionists, though no longer Chovevists. Second: we can be "political" Zionists, though no longer Charterists. I will add a third proposition: practical Zionists must be political Zionists.

Under no circumstances, can we afford to return to the modus operandi of the Chovevists. To assist Jewish settlers in Palestine, to establish genuinely Jewish schools, to encourage Hebrew art and letters, and so on, all this is excellent; and should be accomplished, one may add, by the private, not the public, arm of Zionist - Under no circumstances can we afford to return to the modus operandi of the Chovevists. To assist Jewish settlers in Palestine, to establish genuinely Jewish schools, to encourage Hebrew art and letters, and so on, all this is excellent; and should be accomplished, one may add, by the private, not the public, arm of Zionist ew to the modus operandi of the Chovevists. To assist Jewish settlers in Palestine, to establish genuinely Jewish schools, to encourage Hebrew art and letters, and so on, all this is excellent; and should be accomplished, one may add, by the private, not the public, arm of Zionist—and near-Zionists. But we must clearly understand that this activity is useful, from the point of view of the Basle Program, that is, the Zionist point of view, only as a basis for our political enterprise. Our objective is, not Jews, but an autonomous Jewish people, in Palestine. We must be perpetually on our guard lest we prepare for our future a horse-chestnut in lieu of a chestnut-horse.

Sir, profoundly convinced of the impera-