The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 5 · November 1911
138printed page
scan 20 of 32

EDITORIAL

A REPLY TO DR. KALLEN AND MR. HURWITZ.

We have read with great interest the letters of Dr. Kallen, Mr. Speare and Mr. Hurwitz, which appear elsewhere in this issue, and which are intended as a reproof for our views on the "manifesto" issued by a group of university men, and also for our editorial on "Academic Zionists." Their lucid statement and understanding of the principles of political Zionism leads us to hope that they can be brought to the point of understanding the position taken by THE MACCABAEAN in the matter criticised by them. The editorial pages of THE MACCABAEAN aim at the exposition of the official outlook of Zionism on the variegated contemporaneous incidents of Jewish life. It is not a one-man view that governs the expression of its opinions.

The consideration given to the “manifesto” of our academic friends was based not on its literal meaning, but on its general effect upon Jewish public opinion at the time it was issued. Coming so closely after the Tenth Zionist Congress, issued— as it appeared to us—to swell the cry of protest that arose after the holding of that Congress against the alleged abandonment of political Zionism, the immediate effect of the “manifesto” was to give veracity to the inference that these gentlemen had accepted the general conclusion, and desired to have the Actions Comité know that they still adhered to the tenets of political Zionism in spite of what had occurred at Basle, although, as organization men, they pledged their support to the administration.

It was with the intention of checking any misleading conclusion as to what had happened at Basle that we characterized the “manifesto” as we did. It is our opinion that for all practical purposes, the Zionist movement remains a movement inspired by the political thought of establishing the Jews as an autonomous nationality within the Ottoman empire. That there are surging activities that are forcing the so-called practical work into the foreground is

admitted, for it is all too apparent. The vanguard of the movement, from what we know of the personnel of the Actions Comité, remains, however, national in its objects, and political in its methods.

That there is danger, and has been danger to the political ideal in the vociferous activities of a certain element of our movement in Russia, and among certain thoughtless workers here in the United States, is also admitted. That danger exists, and it is the duty of those among us who see deeper into the conditions of Jewish life and who feel that the political ideal and no other is destined to be the salvation of our national hopes, to undertake an efficient campaign for the acceptance of our ideals among the masses of our comrades.

But that is quite a different thing from what our friends in Boston aimed to accomplish. Their "manifesto" was intended —for that was its effect (and it is a gratuitous criticism to say that we had not read their statement)—to impress upon the public mind the fact that there were gentlemen of academic training who persisted in their allegiance to the Basle program, in spite of the equivocal position of the leaders of the movement. Such a statement was premature and unwarranted, for at the very moment the "manifesto" was received in THE MACCABAEAN office, we had before us the statement issued by the Actions Comité, in which without equivocation the political ideals of the movement were re-affirmed. And, furthermore, since that time, the Actions Comité has been considering, at every one of its meetings, the political facts that seem to demand political action, which the Actions Comité is prepared to take.

Mr. Hurwitz is amazed at our statement that the "manifesto" was a criticism of the Zionist administration, but we could see no other reason for its appearance at the time and in the manner it was published other than the presumption that it was just such a criticism. Had the "manifesto" been submitted first to the Actions Comité