The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 3 · September 1911
79printed page
scan 27 of 28
THE MACCABAEAN

gument, which, I must confess, is rather hard to follow. And the author here applies as a test of nationality, the definition of Renan, as to what constitute a nation; "A nation is then a great solidarity constituted by the sentiment of the sacrifices that its citizens have made, and of those that they feel prepared to make once more. It implies a past; but it is summed up in the present by a tangible fact—consent, the clearly expressed desire to live a common life." And, maintaining that the Jews do not stand this test, the author denies Jewish nationality.

This argument reminds me of a proof recently adduced by a Frenchman from this very definition of Renan, that the Jews do constitute a nation. And, indeed, if this definition be applied to the Jewish people, an unbiased person would necessarily conclude that the latter do stand the test. I need not go far back in history to prove that the Jews have always expressed their desire to live together and to bring sacrifices for the common good. The Jewish Pale in Russia and the various Jewish Ghettos in the western countries are testimony enough to bear out this statement. And even if it be true that among the native Jews in the western countries a speedy process of denationalization is now going on,—this fact would speak no more against the theory that the Jews are a nation, than would the fact that the Germans born in England and America consider themselves Englishmen and Americans, speaks against the nationality of the German nation. But let me say right here, that it is by no means true that all the native and "cultured" Jews of the western countries are speedily and consciously becoming denationalized. It is enough to mention the names of Zangwill, Nordau, Marmorek, Lilien, Oppenheimer, etc., and to cite the fact that most of the Zionist leaders in the western countries are native Jews,—it is enough, I say, to point to those names and facts to prove that Mr. Fishberg's assertion is far from being true.

As for the other arguments of Mr. Fishberg in support of his theory, we find there a good deal of confusion and misstatement of facts. He authoritatively asserts, for example, that "Intellectually also there are no indications of any cultural aspirations of the modern Jews, excepting as citizens of the countries in which they live." And

in the same breath he cites the fact that the Zionists are "everywhere engaged in providing facilities for their members, and Jews in general, to become especially acquainted with the history of their people and intimate with the sacred and profane literature in the Hebrew language,"—a fact that on the face of it, contradicts his previous statement. Besides, he entirely ignores the intensive intellectual and cultural aspirations expressed thru the medium of Yiddish and Hebrew literature. Again, the author makes a false assertion by saying: "Even in eastern Europe, where up to fifty years ago Hebrew was not only the sacred but almost the secular tongue of the Jews, no periodical in that language can now exist; all attempts to publish a Hebrew periodical meet with failure for lack of subscribers." The truth is that more than a score of Hebrew periodicals now exist, including separate periodicals for workmen, children, and pedagogy, and that hundreds of Hebrew books come from the press every year. And thus he continues in the course of his argument, contradicting himself and misstating facts. Here he maintains, with the authority of a connoisseur, that there is no distinctive Jewish art, and immediately quotes Wagner to the effect that there is such a thing as "Jewish" music. And there he denies that there exists a Jewish folklore, and he ignores the distinctively and characteristically Jewish folk-proverbs and songs, several collections of which have already been published.

Finally, I should like to point out another characteristic inaccuracy, which throws light upon the method of Mr. Fishberg in turning things to his own account. In a note on p. 505, the author declares: "Later Renan himself has emphatically denied the existence of a Jewish race;" and in corroboration he quotes the following words of Renan; "I am convinced that there is in the totality of the Jewish people, such as it exists to-day, a considerable portion of non-Semitic blood; so much so, that the race, which is considered the ideal of a pure ethnos, preserving itself for long centuries by the interdiction of mixed marriages, has been strongly penetrated by foreign infusion, almost as much as if has taken place among other races, In other words, Judaism was originally a national religion; it has become again an ex-