III.
Dr. Fishberg, however, denies not only that the Jews are a race, but also that they are a nation, or even a people; and he is very careful thruout his book not to call the Jews by any of these names. That the Jews are not a nation he discusses in the chapter "Assimilation versus Zionism." It is rather surprising to find in a supposedly scientific book a chapter of this kind, the very name of which indicates its journalistic character, and it should, by right, be passed over with a mere mention. But this chapter, too, on the one hand, lays claim to scientific investigation and, on the other, militates against the principle held by some as historically true, namely, that the Jews of to-day do constitute a nation. It is therefore worth
while devoting a few remarks to this chapter.
I shall not attempt here to discuss Zionism, which the author treats in this chapter at length. For this would in itself require a whole article. Besides, this is not science but press opinion. I must, however, remark that the article shows total ignorance of the subject on the part of the author. This may be seen, for example, from some of the arguments which he puts forward against Zionism: "Palestine could not accommodate twelve million Jews" (p. 493), or "Christendom would not allow the Holly Land to be in the hands of the Jews" (ib.. .) as if Zionism aimed at bringing all the Jews of the world together into Palestine, and desired to establish there an independent Jewish government. Or when he makes the following statement: "Realizing the defect in the soil of their sacred land, as well as the shortcomings of their people as regards their deficient proclivities to agriculture the Zionists have changed their program. They declared that the most important task is to develop the country industrially and commercialy" (p. 495),—a statement altogether false. Nor do I intend to enter into a thorogoing discussion as to what constitutes a nation. I merely want to point out the confusion and contradiction to be found in this chapter as regards Jewish nationalism.
Mr. Fishberg at first admits that "A study of the history of the Jews in dispersion, up to the end of the eighteenth century shows that as long as religion is part and parcel of the European states the Jews were undoubtedly a nation" (p. 475). And even to-day, "In Morocco, Persia, etc., the Mohammedans of to-day can not conceive a Christian or Jewish infidel to be of the same nation as themselves. In Russia, where the Greek Church is a state institution, the Jews of to-day show some national characteristics. They speak their own language, Yiddish, etc. (p. 478). And I suppose the author would not exclude Roumania, where the Jews are considered as aliens. Mr. Fishberg argues however, that the "cultured" Jews everywhere, and particularly in the western countries, stand entirely under the influence of the nationalities among whom they live. And, therefore, the Jews art not a nation but a religious sect. This is, indeed, a line of ar-
