The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 3 · September 1911
69printed page
scan 17 of 28
Facsimile · scan 17 of 28
Scan of p. 69
Text · transcribed from the scan

A Study of the Jew

By A. S. WALDSTEIN

(Concluded)

As for the Jewish cast of countenance, Mr. Fishberg carries his conclusions ad absurdum. He denies, despite all living facts and opinions to the contrary, that there is such a thing as a racial Jewish type of face. The so-called Jewish type is not racial but a result of the Ghetto life and this type disappears as soon as the Jew breaks away from the Ghetto. "That the Jewish face, he argues, is characteristic and that a Jew can be singled out from among a thousand Christians is a RECENT OPINION. In Mediaval Ages, the tormentors of the Jews did not place much confidence in the so-called "Jewish" Type as a safe distinguishing mark. It seems they knew appearances are often deceptive. They were, however, determined to know a Jew when they met one, and to avoid mistakes many enactments were promulgated compelling the Jews to wear badges in order that they may be easily distinguished from non-Jews "(p. 92.). And then he adds rather naively: "It appears that to-day things have changed materially in this regard. Even as distinguished an ethnologist as Andree, among many others, writes: "We all know the Jewish type; we easily distinguish the Jew by his facial features, etc." Now if we compare the data brought together by Mr. Fishberg as regards Jewish badges in the Mediaval Ages with the article "Badges" in the Jew. Encycl., we immediately see that his data were taken from the article mentioned. Mr. Fishberg is, mowever, careful not to refer to the latter, because it combats the opinion that the badges were a sign of recognition, but asserts that they were rather a sign of humiliation. Instead, however, of referring to the J. E., Mr. Fishberg refers rather to an article by U. Robert in the Revue des Etudes Juives—a reference likewise to be found in the J. E. Now, this article draws no conclusions as regards the badges, but gives merely the data; what is, however, to be remarked, is that even in the data of U. Robert we find

at least one evidence in favor of the opinion of the J. E. In Pirano, for example, the Jews were not fined if they had hid their badges, provided they had worn them (Revue des Etudes Juives, v. 7 pp. 96).

The most unscientific and absurd argument, however, of Mr. Fishberg in favor of his opinion that there is no Jewish racial type of face, is the fact that we find the Jewish type also among non-Jews (p. 171 ff.) And here Mr. Fishberg goes to the length of citing instances and giving photographs of different individuals among various Caucasian and savage tribes whose faces he alleges, have a Jewish cast3. And Mr. Fishberg does not see that he is flagrantly contradicting himself, in that he admits hereby that there is such a thing as a typical Jewish cast of face. Moreover, later (p. 109-10) we find Mr. Fishberg himself speak of a type of Jewish beauty, and this not of the Ghetto Jew but of the Sephardi, who, according to his own opinion, tasted very little of Ghetto life. Then, again, if it be true that some individuals of the Caucasian race, for example, present a Jewish cast of face, why not argue that they got it by admixture of Jewish blood, since numbers are in favor of the Jews? But this argument of Mr. Fishberg from incidental, individual cases is too absurd to be taken seriously.

Let us then turn to the other somatic characteristic of the Jews, upon which Mr. Fishberg bases his theory: (1) the cephalic index, or the head form and (2) pigmentation, or the color of skin, hair and eyes. As for the first, the Jews of the different countries greatly vary. Among the Jews of Europe, for instance, the percentage of

(Continued on page 76)

3 It must be remarked, in passing, that the choice of the photos is not a happy one. Of the three Japanese girls on page 173, at least two have distinctly non-Jewish faces, and the Yoro-Combo (p. 177) has anything but a Jewish cast of countenance.