much akin to callousness and which miltates against the capacity for self-sacrifice. No, the Jewish hero, the scholar, must be not only learned but pious and devoted. And herein lies the explanation of a trait in the modern orthodox Jew which many have observed and found curious. He will bewatl the fact that he has spent so much for the Talmudic education of his son when the latter ceases to be orthodox and to study the Talmud. It would never occur to him that his son must continue reading his Darwin or his Civil Code after he has once mastered them. When it comes to Jewish learning, however, it is not enough to know. You must also practice and observe. The Jewish scholar-hero must be not only learned but also pious, because piety or Orthodoxy, ¢f you will, has hitherto been the only mode for expression of Jewish nationalism, the form in which his heroism manifested itcelf.
But now, the changes of modern events have brought about a change in the form in which the national heroism of the Jewish scholar must manifest itself. With the progress of modern thought, the peculiar form of religious devotion which preserved the Jewish nation has, like all other forms of religious devotion received a rude shock. A new generation of Jews arises, to which the gates of all learning are magnanimously thrown open by the nations who,hitherto, have kept them shut up in the Ghettos. Eagerly yet anxiously does the old generation urge on the young to go out into the free air and drink at the founts of universal learning, hoping that thus would their children better equip themselves for the struggle which has been transmitted to them through the ages. But, what happens? The young go out and drink their fill at those founts: they become intellectual giants. Worthily and grandly do they remain true to this one tradition of their ancestors. They are at the forefront of intellectual achievement. But, and here lurks the profound tragedy, to the other tradition, that of religious devotion, thy find that they cannot remain true, and should they find no other mode for the expression of their national allegiance, all their signficance as Jewish heroes completely vanishes.
And this has been the case with many—far too many—of this new generation of students and scholars. They do not real-
ize that the Jewish scholar is the only Jewish hero and that on him devolves the duty of carrying an age-long struggle to a victorious finish. Instead, having found no new mode of religious devotion, no new channel for national allegiance and activity, they have become “intellectuals” pure and simple, and some of them are effusive dilettanti, who flit about from flower to flower, sipping a little honey here and there, with a smile on the lip and a hole in the heart; and when such a dilettant is only mediocre, he sips his coffee between cigarette puffs in the wee hours of the morning, and prates about art, but when he is a_ genius he becomes a George Brandes, who has assimilated the spirit of every literature but that of the Jewish. Or, if he is not a dilettant he is an “objective scientist,* who when mediocre can deftly measure a cranium and draw a conclusion which he thinks will satisfy the goy, but when a genius, becomes a Michelson who measures the velocity of light but marries away from his people. \
The Jewish student when deprived of the ballast of pride which springs from national allegiance presents a spectacle which were highly comic if it were not 50 tragic. Without this independence they do not know how to repay the antipathy of their non-Jewish fellow-students with contempt, or to retaliate against some act of discrimination with fearless action or dignified protest. Instead, you can 6 them, those prize students who carry off the honors of the class-room and even those of the athletic field, smirking around their gentile “friends,” faces expressive of a shame-faced, reserved admiration, aping their college “swagger” and “lingo”, beaming with happiness when some _ hollow-pated fool condescends to recognize them in some manner, constantly a-tremble lest they bring to the fore any of their Jewishness, and actually snubbing their fellow-Jews. Without moral equilibrium, they present a pitiable spectacle, they seem to be constantly apologizing, and such is the degree of their self-abasement that they find it hard to believe the meager account which is given them in their courses of the role which the Jews have played in the history of civilization. There seems to be no middle ground for the Jewish scholar and student. If, the rit-
