A Study of the Jew*
It is the first time that an all-embracing study of the Jews, in their ethnographic, demographic, physical, social, and political aspect, has been attempted. And _ indeed, the names of the chapters alone are enough to indicate the ambitious pretensions of the author: “Number and Distribution of the Jews.” “Physical Characters “Types of Jews,” “Demographic Characteristics,” “Pathological Characteristics,” ete, ete. Of all these chapters, however, the richest in material are 2, 3, and 4 on the physical characteristics of the Jews, and a few others which are instructive in so far as they establish the fact, that in some tharacteristics, such as the head form, the Jews present not a homogeneous but a heterogeneous people: and even in pigmentation (the color of the skin, hair, and eves) there is a great divirgence from the traditional “Jewish” or Semitic type. Of the other chapters, as as we shall see later, some are rather meager in material, or do not go beyond the domain of journalism.
Dr. Fishberg's book would thus, as a whole, have been a valuable contribution to the study of the Jews, were it not for the fact that it is throughout marred by tendency and an a priori subjective view of the author as regards the Jews, in spite of his promise, in the preface, to treat the matter collectively. Mr. Fishberg's tendencies are assimilatory, and these private tendencies he uses as feelers, so to say, at every step in investigation he makes. Hence we meet in the book with all the contradiction, unfounded assertions, overhasty conclusions, and other unscientific elements characteristic of an a priori opinion.
Mr. Fishberg denies not only that the Jews are a race, but also that they are a nation, or even a people. This denial he bases upon historical data as well as upon the investigation of the somatic (physical) characteristics of the modern Jew. In his
* The Jews: A study of Race and Environment, By Dr. M. Fishberg, in the Contemporary Science Series., 1911.
historic data, he naturally lays great weight upon “Proselytism and Intermar- riage’ both during Jewish independence and during the diaspora. Here he turns to account even the most obscure and doubtful cases exaggerating them and Stating them as sure historic facts, in order to carry his point. In the tine 01+ the pre-Babylonian — exile, when he can find only single cases of intermarriage between Jews and non-Jews! he yet intuitively, as it seems, assumes that there was then a great “racial mixture.’ and immediately jumps to the following conclusion: “It appears that the diversity of physical type of mankind in Egypt, Syria, Palestine, Mesopotamia, ete., Was at least as great as that seen to-day in Europe. .\nd judging by the small extent of the region under consideration and the small number of inhabitants, racial nuixtures should leave a profound impression upon the type of the Hebrew” (p. 183). But suppose there was then no“racial mixture to the extent of affecting the type of the 11607642 For even Mr. Fishberg himself could cite only single instances of intermarriage. And if we, moreover, bear in mind the religious exclusiveness of the Jews even at that time, we must, by dint of solid fact, come to the conclusion that the intiltration of foreign blood was then so slight as to affeet but little the racial traits of the Hebrews.
Mr. Fishberg also makes much of the conversions to Judaism during the Grico- Roman period of Jewish history. And indeed, if we look at these conversions superficially, it would seem as 1 8 would bear out the author's theory. Josephus speaks with elation of conversions en masse and the Greek and Roman writ-
1. It may be remarked, by the way, that the author cites here some instances which show ignorance: "Solomon, himself the son of a Hittite woman" (p. 182); "The mother of king Hiram married a Syrian" (ibid.), confounding Hiram the coppersmith with the Phenician king of the same name (cf. 1 Kings 7, 13-14).