EDITORIAL PAGES
THE RESULTS OF THE TANNERSVILLE CONVENTION
This issue of THE MACCABAEAN is a convention number. It is intended as a record of the fourteenth annual convention of the Federation of American Zionists.
Necessarily a written record can give over very little of the spirit that governs any given event, and especially so is it the case in this instance, for whatever the record may disclose, only those who were present and who participated in the conferences, are able to recall the emotions aroused, the good feeling that prevailed, and the general atmosphere which is, probably, the best value of any convention.
The Pittsburg convention of the year before, it will be recalled, disclosed a state of affairs which seemed to involve our organization in calamity and disruption. That convention was the striking of a balance sheet of two years, and what that sheet revealed, those who were present prefer to forget.
At the Tannersville convention, however, only echoes of the Pittsburg record were heard. It seemed as if the Federation had gone through a year of penance and had emerged out of it with a clear conscience, with renewed vigor, and with a feeling of hope such as our movement in this country has never experienced.
Before the convention we were discussing the "crisis in Zionism." To-day, we feel that the crisis, if there was one, has passed, and as we read the preliminary news of the Tenth Congress, we are conscious of the fact that among our comrades in Europe, also the crisis has passed. Zionism is emerging into the clear atmosphere where agitation, propaganda and practical work in the direction of increasing Jewish influence in Palestine, will have a field unhindered by the petty obstacles that have hitherto obstructed our progress.
The movement in America has suffered because of the peculiar timidity of Zionist
leaders, who have felt that the movement, as represented by our present organization, did not warrant the sacrifice of their personal careers; and that if Zionist work is to be done it could be done by the individual untrammelled by responsibilities to an organization which did not show adequate signs of life, and was constantly on the verge of financial collapse. They felt with justice that the work they had to do in the Jewish world should not be confined to the small circle of Zionist influence. In Zionist circles, it was necessary to work with meager assistance and support; while if they made an impression upon other sections of Jewish life, the fact that they were Zionists would react upon the Zionist movement and bring it ultimately a larger measure of support.
In our opinion, this lack of adventuresomeness was at bottom of the halting nature of our propaganda. There were few among us who saw a communal or literary or intellectual career in the Zionist ranks, and as a result, even though circumstances had forced us into the Zionist organization, we went into it with a half-hearted interest, irritated by petty criticism, giving grudgingly of our time and thought, and in the end, although sacrificing a great deal to the movement, actually accomplishing very little for it because of our divided attention. "Half a loaf is better than none," is a maxim that does not hold true here.
It is to be credited to the Tannersville convention that it has made clear this defect in leadership, and it remains to be seen whether the new administration, which has in it a number of new men, will be able to have its personnel so concentrate all their individual efforts solely to Zionism, as to stand out in the community as examples of Zionist self-sacrifice.
We are to be congratulated as well upon the unanimity of opinion that greeted the proposal to enter into the work of introducing Zionism among the fraternal organizations, and to bring the movement into closer relations with the synagogue. The