The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 6 · June 1911
165printed page
scan 7 of 32
THE MACCABAEAN
165

by the re-nationalisation of Jews, Zionists do not desire the recreation of the ghetto. In such an interpretation of the word, Zionism no more than Liberal Judaism would seek the re-establishment of the ghetto. For what is the actual fact? Zionism sets itself the task of forming a national centre of Judaism in the full enjoyment of political freedom, where the conditions will provide a complete Jewish environment, Jewish atmosphere, and Jewish culture.

In as far as the national centre will ensure the existence of this Jewish environment, Jewish atmosphere, and Jewish culture, there will be a recreation of the ghetto. But in as far as the national centre will not reproduce the political restrictions and social ostracism of the ghetto, it will not be a ghetto, but a land of liberty like other countries of freedom.

Liberal Judaism has therefore much to gain by throwing in its lot with Zionism, and for this reason. [ began by saying that there are two tendencies in human nature, Conservatism and Liberalism. When the Zionist programme is realised, the national centre of Judaism will not be immune fron the characteristics of human nature, and the two tendencies of Conser- vatiem and Liberalism will spontaneously assert themselves in the development of the national life. There will then inevitably be one party devoted to Conservative Judaism and one party devoted to Liberal Judaism. For example, it was when the Jews were still a nation that the Rabbis and the Synagogues began to take the place of the Priests and the Temple, and it was when the Jews were still in their own land that, after the destruction of the Temple, prayer was substituted for sacrifice.

Thus, with the realisation of the hopes and aims of Zionism, Liberal Judaism in the Diaspora would find itself associated with and could co-operate with Liberal Judaism at the natiohal centre. As Liberal Jews in every country now claim still tu belong to the religious brotherhood of Israel, they cannot consistently be disinclined to be identified with Liberal Judaism in the national centre. The geographical boundaries of nations do not form the frontiers of human hearts, and territorial limits do not constitute barriers against the muttal aspirations of the souls of a teligious fraternity. Hence, Zionism from

the very centre of Judaism would act as a guide and an inspiration to the safe and wise pursuit of Liberal Judaism in the Diaspora, and the cause of Liberal Judaism at the centre would be encouraged and strengthened by the adherence of and support from Liberal Judaism in the Diaspora.

IE 0 gf TEI IIE ISIE --- At the centre of national life there would be a field for the free play of the two different forces of Conservative Judaism and Liberal Judaism. Liberal Judaism would exercise its due influence in the national life by virtue of the legitimate opportuni ties it would enjoy of endeavoring to persuade the whole nation to an acceptance of its views. Thus, for Liberal Judaism as well as for Conservative Judaism, the Law would again go forth out of Zion, and the word of the Lord from Jerusalem, radiating their benign influence far and wide to the ende of the earth.

There is an attractive account in the Talmud of an incident in the career of Rav Ashi, when King Manasseh appeared to him in a dream. In the course of their learned duologue, Rav Ashi exclaimed, "Since thou art indeed so wise, how comes it that thou didst worship idols? Manasseh thereupon retorted, 'Hadst thou lived in those days, even thou wouldst have lifted thy skirt to run quickly after me, and thou wouldst also have worshipped idols'" (Sanhedrin, 102 b).

We have. therefore, even in the case of great and independent minds, frankly to recognise the subtle and powerful influence of environment, and the streneth of the human inclination to follow the habits and customs and example of the majority. Now the Jews in the Diaspora must always be in a minority in the countries where they dwell, and will always be liable to the fate of minorities to be absorbed in the majority. Liberal Jews have to contend with the added disadvantage and danger of being the minority of a minority, with a relaxed sense of the value and importance of ceremonial which makes for religious exclusiveness, and with an intensified bias in the direction of gentile culture which tends to fusion.

If Liberal Judaism is to remain keenly and proudly aware of its own separate existence, and to preserve the character which it claims of being the expression of a new spiritual recovery, it requires some energising force to arrest the process of decline