cution has involved the concentration of Jews, and that Liberal Judaism has flourished most in those communities where emancipation, with its attendant advance in material comfort and growth in the acquisition of cosmopolitan culture, has led to the decentralisation of Jews, and this ditfusion, in its turn, has produced disintegration and the dissolution of the cohesive forces of conscious unity.
The continuance of Judaism, then, is dependent on the existence of an area with an aggregation of Jews living in a Jewish environment, breathing a Jewish atmosphere and fostering a Jewish culture, and these factors must predominate over all other influences.
Does this conclusion, then, mean that Judaism can only thrive under persecution, that Judaism cannot stand the sunshine of freedom, and that, if we really wish to preserve our faith, we should entirely abandon the advocacy and the promotion of the cause of liberty of conscience for the Jew in all countries of the globe? I do not think in the least that we are confronted with such a dilemma. We are completely justified in asserting the claim of Jews to possess equal rights with their fellow-citizens in whatever country they may be, and it is the incontestable duty of Jews who enjoy the fruits of political freedom in any part of the world to help their brethren in less fortunate lands to obtain similar rights and to aid in hastening the day when the Jew, wherever he may be, will become a free man in a free land.
None of us who have tasted freedom will ever be willing to sacrifice it without a keen struggle. At the same time we know that emancipation provides the best soil for the birth of Liberal Judaism, and that seemingly the invariable outcome of Liberal Judaism in a gentile environment is absorption.
We must also acknowledge the verdict of history that it is Conservative Judaism which is the Judaism, because it alone always survives. We must also face the fact that Conservative Judaism has been maintained in the aggregation of Jews in communities subject to oppression, yet none of us will be prepared to plead to be persecuted, if acquiescence in and submission to persecution are the only means for the preservation of our religion.
How shall we meet the undoubted difficulty to which attention has just been
drawn? I think the difficulty has been grossly exaggerated through being stated in a wrong or misleading form. The problem is generally framed and summarised in the question, "Are we a nation or a religious community?" I do not regard this as an entirely fair or satisfactory statement of the point at issue, because it leads to a confusion in thought and an unnecessary antagonism between Conservative Judaism and Liberal Judaism.
Liberal Judaism would say, "Israel among the nations. We are a religious brotherhood in the midst of the nations. Our nationality is the land in which we live. Our religion is the religion of Judaism, adapted to the peculiar conditions of the country in which we dwell, and we abandon all those elements in our religion which seek or imply a restoration of the Jewish people as a nation."
Conservative Judaism would say, "Israel a nation. Technically we are not a nation now. But although we object to persecution and claim freedom as strongly as Liberal Judaism, yet we mean what we pray, and we do look forward to the re-establishment of the Jews as a nation."
I therefore think the contrast is too sharply drawn when we are asked to decide, "Are we a nation or a religious community?" I object to the disjunctive "or," and would replace it by the conjunction "and." We form a religious brotherhood, and must maintain and try to realise the national hopes of Judaism.
I shall probably be told that the re-establishment of the Jews as a nation would mean the recreation of the Ghetto. I am frankly prepared to admit the force of this criticism, but with an important qualification dependent on the interpretation of the word "ghetto."
If by a "ghetto" we mean the aggregation of individuals within a definite area, having similar traditions and practices, and pursuing similar aims, then, in this sense, every nation is a "ghetto" on a larger or smaller scale, and the smaller nations of Europe, with populations less than the total number of Jews in the world, are also "ghettoes."
But if by a "ghetto" we mean the concentration of Jews in an area, where, in the old sense of the term, the inhabitants of that area are subject to disabilities and restrictions and harassing persecution, then
