Mill, in his “Logic,” quotes Lord Mansfield’s counsel to a man of practical good sense, who, being appointed governor of a colony, had to preside in its court of justice, without previous legal education or judicial practice. The advice tendered was that the judge should give his decision boldly, for it would probably be right, but never to venture on assigning his reasons, for they would almost infallibly be wrong. Similarly, my particular illustrations may not command general assent, but my conclusion will not, I think, be seriously contested, that Conservative Judaism shows an orderly development, and the greater the Rabbi the more he proves himself able and willing to avoid the language and tone of passionate conflict, to find a temperate solution of critical problems in religious progress, and to sanction a wise and smooth and tranquil adjustment of old forms to new ideas and new conditions, without any controversial disquiet or violent disturbance of the religious atmosphere.
And now comes the remarkable paradox. On the one hand, as I have been trying tu demonstrate, Conservative Judaism show: an orderly development in the gradual absorption of Liberal views, but the guiding policy has been flecti non frangi (“to be bent, not to be broken”), and the changes introduced have always been conservative modifications within the bounds of orthodox principles. On the other hand, Libera: Judaism is of necessity always exposed to one or two dangers, either absorption from within or fusion from without.
When Liberal Judaism proceeds along evolutionary lines of religious development, its difference from Conservative Judaism is not a difference in the interpretation of the essence of progress, but a difference in the attempted rate of progress. When Liberal Judaism succeeds in affecting the trend of Conservative Judaism, its task is ended, and it becomes absorbed in the Conservative Judaism which its influence has modified or transformed. It is the liability to this fate which constitutes the internal danger with Liberal Judaism always threatened.
When Liberal Judaism ruthlessly snaps the chain of tradition, seeks to produce a clear-cut new development, and abandons the inspiration of history, then, by the sheer stress of facts, its inward or centri-
petal power of resistance against the vigour of the outward or centrifugal tendency is inevitably weakened, and its gradual absorption by a gentile environment becomes an ultimate certainty. It is the liability to this fate which constitutes the external danger with Liberal Judaism is always threatened.
So, in broad outline, it is a curious fact that the Judaism which has persisted is Conservative Judaism, and the Judaism which. has perished is Liberal Judaism. The best instance of Conservative Judaism absorbing within itself Liberal modes of thought and practice is the golden age of Judaism in Spain. The best instance of Liberal Judaism harmonising inherited religion with acquired environment is the Hellenistic Judaism of Alexandria. The Conservative Judaism of Spain survived the expulsion from Spain. The Liberal Judaism of Alexandria faded out of existence before the advance and spread of Christianity.
What is the explanation of this difference in fate? In Spain, the emphasis was on the “Judaism,” and not on the “Spanish.” In Alexandria, the emphasis was on the “Hellenistic,” and not on the “Judaism.” In each case, the nature of the environment helps to yield the secret of the different consequences. In Spain, the similarities between Judaism and Mohammedanism outweighed the differences of faith in application to daily life. In Alexandria, the differences between Judaism and Hellenism were far greater than the area of agreement or likeness. Similarly, in Germany, in the nineteenth century, the Reform movement became more German than Jewish, and this led, on the whole, to Reform Judaism being swallowed up in Christianity.
Why, then, has it happened that Conservative Judaism, while showing itself capable of modification, has not shared the fate of Liberal Judaism, and why is it a stern fact, which has to be reckened with, that the Judaism which has persisted through the centuries is Conservative Judaism? I think the explanation will be found in the external political conditions which have produced their internal consequences. Outward circumstance has created inward necessity. Roughly speaking, it may be said that Conservative Judaism has been preserved in those communities where perse-