The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 6 · June 1911
162printed page
scan 4 of 32
162
THE MACCABAEAN

currents when we endeavor to apply general principles to particular instances.

Using, then, the terms Conservative Judaism and Liberal Judaism in their wider signification, the first point I wish to urge is that Conservative Judaism, while observing a due norm of restraint and reverence for the past. has never been a religion of changelessness, paralysing all growth and development. It is of paramount importance to remove the erroneous notion that Conservative Judaism inevitably and invar- iably spells reaction or rigidity. If we closely examine the history of our religion from its creation as Hebraism, through its passage into Judaism, and its evolution into its present form to-day, I think we shall find that Conservative Judaism has always betrayed the features of a living organism, and without swerving from the straight path of development or losing its essential individuality, has made ordered progress In adapting itself to new needs called forth by the lapse of time and made insistent by change of conditions and environment.

Let me give a few illustrations in proof of such development in Conservative Judaism, both in doctrine and practice, where solid and enduring harmony has been promoted and real progress has been ensured by the wise setting of the passing season "in chime with seasons played out long ago," and seasons yet to come.

(a) In the moment of doctrine we may point to the momentous change from monolatry to monotheism, the transition from the worship of God as a tribal, local, or national deity, to the recognition of God as God of the whole world, so that in the phraseology of the Prayer Book, "our God, and God of our fathers" is also "our God, King of the universe."

(b) In the domain of ceremonial there have been the gradual changes in the attitude towards the sacrificial system, and since the destruction of the Temple prayer has been regarded as the substitute for sacrifice.

(c) In the sphere of ritual it is now a commonplace to say that the Jewish Liturgy is not fixed, but has always been more or less fluid, and that, for instance, round the recital of the Shema and the Amidah as central ideas, there have been many additions to the Prayer Book in different ages.

(d) Then there has also been an evolu-

tion in the interpretation of laws laid down even in the Bible itself. Thus, in temperate and cold zones, fires are allowed on the Sabbath in strict homes of Conservative Judaism, in spite of the injunction in Exodus XXXV. 3, "Ye shall kindle no fire throughout your habitations upon the Sabbath day."

(e) Again. in the sphere of human relations, there has been the submission to the decree of Rabbinu Gershom for the institution of monogamy. Further, there has been the acceptance of the voluntary prohibition of marriages permitted according to Jewish law, but in conflict with the laws of the land in which Jews happen to live. For example, the marriage of uncle and niece is allowed according to Jewish law, but the synagogue in this country does not countenance and would not solemnise such a union, because it would not be sanctioned by the law of England.

It may be objected that I am here quoting instances where Conservative Judaism has made new restrictions and has stiffened Jewish law. Let me therefore now recall an example of relaxation of Jewish law.

An 'Agunah' is "a woman whose husband has either abandoned her, or being absent, has not been heard from for some time. Having no proof of her husband's death, or being without a bill of divorce from him, her status as a wife remains for ever unchanged; for Jewish law does not admit the presumption of death from a prolonged absence merely, nor can a wife obtain a divorce from an absent husband. In order to mitigate the hardship arising from such cases the Rabbinical law relaxed the strict rules regarding evidence, and accepted testimony that in other cases would not be been deemed competent." (Jewish Encyclopaedia, "Agunah").

Thus, in the realm of marriage and divorce We can trace two tendencies, the one making for increased stringency, and the other making for increased leniency. On the one hand, there is an enlargement of the table of kindred and affinity in which marriages are forbidden, and a limitation of the grounds of divorce, to secure in both cases a greater harmony between Jewish law and the law of the land; and, on the other hand, there is the gradual introduction and institution of regulations which in practice and effect place women in a position of greater equality with men.