The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 5 · May 1911
154printed page
scan 24 of 30

stration of the wish of the Jews to return to their national home. The shekel contribution was a contrivance to register the number of pious wishes to be found among the Jewish people.

Necessarily, these Zionists had not been trained in the practice of organization: they had not been trained in patience: they had little or no historical sense; and they expected the coming of the Redemption any day.

All our difficulties—our seeming inability to rear the structure of a permanent and effective organization on this foundation—have been due to the fact that we have not gotten out of our system the weakness that came in with the first flush of the movement. There could not be formed a perfectly drilled and trained standing army, when all in that army were not fully qualified for the long march ahead of the movement.

We need now an army of willers, who are determined to realize the aims of the movement, no matter how long it may take. These crises, of which the enemy make so much of, are nothing but alterations in the position of the Jewish people. Zionism is unlike everything else in Jewish Life intended merely to preserve old relics; it is not a study of antiquities; it is not the maintenance of the status quo. It is, above every thing else, a dynamic movement, filled with life, moving forward, encountering difficulties, suffering from wounds inflicted, and fighting back. It is Jewish life on the march; and it will not cease, and cannot cease its activities, until the last man of us loses hope, faith, and the will to realize.

THE FRENCH ALLIANCE IN CONSTANTINOPLE.

THE President of the Zionist organization has replied to the defense of the Alliance Universelle Israelite when charged with instigating the agitation in Constantinople against Zionism, and has effective-

ly proven, it seems to us, that the unpleasant situation was created by agents of the French organization, acting with its approval and for the definite object of discrediting Zionism.

The French Alliance shows, in this instance, that it has not trained in the school of French democrats, but that it has received all it knows of political activities from the Society of Jesuits, with whom the end always justified the means, and to whom a lie was no lie unless it was told in the interests of wrong. Believing in nothing that Zionism stands for repudiating the right of Jews to their own national culture, their rights as a separate people, their future, and even in their past the French Alliance feels justified in spreading calumnies, and having spread these calumnies, it does not scruple to deny, in diplomatic language, that it has been guilty of wrong doing.

President Wolffshon may be criticised for his lack of tact in thus unmasking this organization, and compelling it to face the charge of falsitication of fact, but while diplomacy may have resulted in maintainins for a while the appearance of being friendly toward the Alliance, this open rupture with an organization untrue to its trust will in the long run redound to the benett of our cause.

RECEIVED FOR MACCABAEAN FUND:

Yiddish Volk1.00
Dr. J. L. Magnes, New York50.00
Louis Lipsky, New York10.00
Bernard G. Richards, New York10.00