sciousness that even a non-sovereign and landless nation has the right to demand full recognition, together with definite rights of national culture. In the first half of the nineteenth century the national question had not yet come to the fore in European political history; its turn came in the second half, after the series of movements in the direction of national liberty following on the year 1848.
i, ir Jn nit For a time it seemed as though the nineteenth century would really fix a landmark in Jewish history: as though the oldest tation, that had for thousands of years maintained its existence in the face of all Political and cultural storms the whole world over, had given in, and at last given up its existence, lowering itself to the level of a religious sect, which, piece by piece, would enter into the composition of other nations. It seemed as though the bona fides of some, and the pia fraus of others, or rather the combination of both with respect to these statements of renunciation, were accepted on trust by other nations, and that this cultural crisis, completed in the West of Europe, would inevitably burst upon the East of Europe. There, however, was enacted the crisis of the crisis. Two factors, one negative and one pos tive, powerfully intercepted the initial process of national dissolution which was alrcady in progress. These two factors were Western anti-Semitism and the fate of the bulk of Jewry in Russia.
The anti-Semites of all nations told those Jews who had obtained emancipation by renouncing their Jewish nationality: “We do not believe in your re- nouncement: you remain strangers among us, in spite of your efforts after assimilation; you are not only of a different confession, but of different stock from us.” The fate of Russian Jewry restored the clear vision of historical consciousness to many who had apparently lost it. Since the time of the cultural crisis of the days of Mendelssohn and of the French Revolution the ways of Western and Eastern Judaism had parted. The former hegemony of the German-Polish Jews, founded on strictly civil and national isolation, was divided; the German Jews abandoned the old foundations and went the way of European enlightenment and assimilation ; the Polish Jews, who then already belonged partly to Russia and partly to Austria.
preserved their individuality, and yieldes. only after dogged resistance to the new cultural influences. Western breezes persistently penetrated the East, inviting them also to enlightenment, to assimilation, to a struggle for civil equality, and even to the well-tried methods of self-effacement (as in the period 1860-1880). But this cultural crisis had not yet contrived to penetrate to the heart of Eastern Jewish society before there set in the reaction of 1881-1905, with its mediaeval persecutions and the horrors of the pogroms. The blows fell on this Eastern bulk of Jewery exactly at the moment when, on the one hand, its old supply of national energy had not as yet failed, and when, on the other hand, the upper crust of enlightened society had accumulated a certain fund of new cultural energy which urged them to. struggle for liberty. The union of the two elements produced a more complexed form of struggle for existence than in the West-—a national movement toward self-liberation.
This new movement branched out in two directions: one was that of a territorial segreation of the Jews, or, anyhow, of a portion of them, from the universal diaspora to a reorganization on autonomous lines, which is expressed in Zionism or Territorialism; the other direction is followed by those who reckon such segregation unrealizable in any measure capable of dealing with the life of the whole nation, and who would rather strive after a national cultural regeneration of the Jewish people in the Dispersion itself, by way of a simultaneous struggle for both civil and national rights in every land. The adherents of both parties agree in this, that the Jews of every country should vindicate their rights as parts of the single historical Jewish nation, not as parts of other national organisms foreign to them. These aspirations had crystallized into definite political passwords when the Russian Revolution broke out in 1905, and the majority of the Jewish political parties tighting for emancipation followed the Jewish national flag. Had not the fatal conditions of actual life in Russia dealt a blow at the revolution itself, we should now be witnesses of a third emancipation—the Russian, accorded not to Jews wearing a Russian national mask, but to millions