I believe that the word of command issued by your vice-president in this letter lacks nothing in definiteness. The motive which can have prompted your vice-president to pen such a letter are all the more inexplicable to me, inasmuch as you expressly point out yourself that Ottoman Jews in your opinion are perfectly able to decide what their duty is and what their real interests are as Jews and as Ottoman citizens.
You inform me —and I had hardly expected anything else—that all those who are qualified to speak in the name of the Alliance have received the instruction to hold themselves aloof from all religious and political conflicts. Unfortunately the following facts contradict this declaration, namely, that in the whole of Turkey your schools are the centres of the hostile spirit by which we are attacked, that your Constantinople school authorities are conducting a stubborn fight against the Gymnastic Society “Maccabi” suspected of Zionism, and that one of your teachers in Salonica is a prominent leader of the local anti-Zionist agitation. It can hardly be unknown to you that there is no Jew in the whole of Turkey who is in doubt that the Alliance is against Zionism and attacks it. You can also hardly wonder that your instructions urging peace and
neutrality do not find the desired attention, when the members of your supreme executive show such an example.
Believe me, a controversy with you is just as painful to me as it may appear to you. I therefore confine myself to the foregoing refutations, which seemed to me absolutely necessary, and omit a great deal It is with deep regret that I have seen from your letter that you do not recognize the necessity of an intervention, by means of which an end could be put to the fraternal strife which continues to rage to the detriment of the welfare of Ottoman Jewry.
"I shall continue to esteem and admire, as I have always done, the high aims to which the Alliance devotes itself and the grand work which it has accomplished in many spheres. I shall as always heartily support its philanthropic and social endeavors, and condemn and prevent any opposition to them, so far as in my power lies. I therefore continue to hope that the administrators of your body will recall the spirit which animated the great founders of the Alliance, the spirit which found expression in its magnanimous motto.
The correspondence was made public in the first instance by the Alliance organ in Holland.
