more moderation. We can only repeat that we have indicated above: the Alliance has neither provoked nor encouraged the campaign. No organization in Turkey, no newspaper, no writer has ever received from us either a word of command or any subsidy whatsoever. The movement has taken place beyond our range; we have not even been called upon to give an instruction or advice. The Ottoman Israelites are able to judge on what side their duty is and where their interest is as Israelites and Ottoman subjects. Those who are qualified to speak in the name of the Alliance have received an instruction to remain aloof from religious or political struggles. They confine themselves to this neutrality and we understand that they will remain in the future, as they have in the past, outside all agitations. The polemics of which you speak not having been encouraged by us and none of our agents having been engaged therein, we do not know to whom our counsels of moderation should be addressed. We wish with you that the polemics which you deplore shall cease, and with you also, we look forward most sincerely to the end of a controversy which can only be prejudicial to Ottoman Judaism.
HERR WOLFFSOHN'S LETTER.
This letter contained so much of what was contrary to the known facts, that Herr Wolffsohn replied as follows:
Your representation that the Zionist Organization began an extensive propaganda in the press immediately after the Turkish Revolution, that nothing, absolutely nothing, was done on your part to thwart our plans, but that we had vehemently attacked and even slandered the circles and persons who held aloof from our idea— this representation rests from beginning to end upon assumptions which cannot be brought into harmony with historic events for which there is documentary evidence.
In July, 1908, the new turn of events took place in Turkey and it continued untn the summer of 1909 before a regular Zionist propaganda began in certain Turkish papers. But before this was the case you received at your office in Paris the Turkish Parliamentary Deputation sent 0 Europe, and on this occasion you delivered zs, speech in which you characterised Zionism
as contrary to Turkish interests, and made out and emphasized a sharp contrast between it and the Alliance. This was the first public attack and you will not deny that it proceeded from you.
You also maintain in your letter that no organization in Turkey, no newspaper, no writer has ever received a word of command or a subvention from you. This contention can also not be supported by the facts. For in the summer of 1909, when I myself was in Constantinople, a communique upon the reception of the Turkish delegation and upon your speech was forwarded to your Constantinople representative M. Fernandez for the purpose of further dissemination, and he, through M. Benveniste, the director of the Alliance School in Constantinople (Galata) sent it to a large number of papers with the request that they publish it.
Your contention that no newspaper has ever received a word of command from you, lacks justification, in my opinion, in the light of the following fact. A few months ago your vice-president, M. Salomon Reinach, addressed a letter to M. David Fresco, the editor of El Tiempo which appears in Constantinople, a newspaper which, after the disclosures of the last few months, I hardly need characterize any further. This letter reads as follows:
“I have often had occasion to speak about Zionism with eminent representatives of Young Turkey, friends as they all are, of the Alliance Israelite Universelle. I was afraid that they took the movement seriously which is both reactionary and chimerical, and which in a country like present-day Turkey is not only incompatible with loyalty but also with ocmmon sense. I have always found, with a genuine sense of relief. that the gentlemen with whom I spoke had no illusions in regard to the importance and real strength of Zionism. I see in Zionism two elements: one. eminently worthy of sympathy, the misery of the oppressed Israelites in Russia and Roumania, who take refuge in dreams to escape from the reality which crushes them; the other, in my opinion, of very little worth, which is the ambition, the thirst for advertisement of certain agitators. In the countries in which the Jews are persecuted Zionism can be a consoling chimera; in Turkey it is a stupidity.”