The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 3 · March 1911
120printed page
scan 42 of 54

with the time, age and people portrayed as to appear ludicrous in the extreme, and the effect is lost upon the reader, be he young or old, boy or man. But it should also be admitted that the latter portion of the work, dealing with the adult Mendelsshon, beginning with his entry into Berlin, his struggles in that city to obtain both an education and footing, ending with his brilliant triumph over all the great obstacles and his subsequent recognition and hailing by all as one of the greatest philosophers and master-minds of the age, is treated in a more reasonable manner, in a more human and true-to-life fashion.

The book bears on its very face the un-

istakable evidences of a "purpose," which the author has set before himself before writing; that it was not the childhood of Moses Mendelsshon that he wished to portray so much as the imparting to the American juvenile reader of some information concerning the life and action of the Jew of the past ages, which is now, alas, disappearing and becoming more and more of a rarity, a book sealed to the rising generation, and if it be admitted that such was his aim, need we be surprised that instead of an entertaining story we have a sermon or a lecture, or better, still, a whole series of them, which with all respect to the author, we can not recognize as belonging to a work of fiction.