lives of historical personages, in that, though it is written in the form of a story, it is not a romance, and no woman, except for one brief allusion, figures in 4 It is rather an imaginative description of the boyhood, youth and early manhood of the great philosopher and Jewish patriot, of his struggles, ambitions and achievements, as we known them from historical records to which is added, now and then, a dash of imagination and description. But the hook is conceived in such a romantic and impossible strain; is written in such a sentimental style, as to remind one strongly of the delicious but impossible romances of Miss. Muhlback and her less capable American imitator, Augusta Evans, and others of their stamp. Any one who is the least bit acquainted with the life and thought of our people in the Germany of two centuries ago, where the “golden days” of emancipation and modern enlightenment set in, their thoughts. views, knowledge and information on secular topics and culture, will be surprised at the words of wisdom which drip like honey from the lips of the presumably uneducated and unsophisticated Mendel, the scribe of the provincial town of Dessau, and father of Moses Meadelssohn! How this. self-same Mendel, obscure scribe to the Jews of Dessau, maker of their phylacteries and door-post amulets, has bridged the chasm of centuries and gives repeated and matter-of-fact utterance to the thoughts and ideas which poor deluded humanity is beginning to discover only lately, within the last decade or two, and outstrips Renan, Harnack and other Bible critics and savants by a full century and more, and all by the magical aid of Dr. Isaacs and his great learning!
The Christian boy, Max, who sits at the festive board of the Mendels on Friday night, listens reverently to the Kiddush and gives utterance to such lofty sentiments and dreams, does violence by his intrusion into a circle which, in those days at least, formed a barrier, which no one dared disturb or disarrange, and reminds us of the adopted Christian boy invariably introduced into the English melodrama of Jewish life and which becomes, as a matter of course, no more than a travesty of life. The sentiments uttered, the sparkling and witty conversation are out of harmony with the general tenor of the surroundings and people, and the whole scene between little Moses
(age ten) and the Christian lads at the fishing banks, their grave theological and sociological discussions, is provokingly unnatural. Listen to but one of the philosophical profundities given utterance to by Moses on that occasion:
"You are wrong, Mr. Wilhelm, the Romans killed him (Jesus). They were the rulers then. The Jews had no power. Besides, to stone to death, not to crucify, was the Jewish method of killing, although, very, very rarely practiced." (Page 27) And further on, in the course of the same argument, "Where would your religion be today if your Saviour had not been killed as you believe?" and a thousand other such words of wisdom. And further on, when he makes the little Moses (who has never yet seen any book but the Pentateuch and the Talmud) speak of the "seven wonders of the world," glad "to show that he knew something about history," or causes his father to explain the meaning of the Jewish prayers (still to the Christian lad), an explanation which is so masterly and convincing that his youthful auditor feels constrained to exclaim in bewildered tones that he "hears often about Jewish narrowness and yet here, in your daily prayers, how could the Jew be broader" or, a little later on, causes again the wonderful Mendel to utter this bit of advice to the Christian boy, that "young people should live together without disputing about religious beliefs"; the introduction of the "vagrant rabbi from Constantinople" whose vast knowledge in the several and sundry fields of history, geography, besides theology and other sciences, would have secured him a professorial chair in any American university, the conversation "wholly in Hebrew" which he carried on with Mendel on such scientific topics and in which both seemingly were at home, the roving Rabbi's knowledge of the existence of the recently-discovered Jewish colony in China, his equally great knowledge of the "Yellow Jews," "Black Jews" and all the thousand and one other things of interest—all of which knowledge he gained while traveling in search of the river Sambatyon," which flows for six days and rests on the Sabbath and on the banks of which dwell the lost Ten Tribes!"
All this seems so unnatural, so forced and inartistic, so much out of harmony
