dressing this was truism, as unnecessary to prove as existence itself. He had other difficulties to overcome, difficulties arising from well-meant precautions taken by the sages of old, who foresaw a long and tedious exile for Israel. He was confronted with old-established notions regarding a Messiah and a miraculous redemption which had to be interpreted or removed by dialectic reasoning and supported by authoritative opinion. Different as were these two men, they still found common ground on which to stand, they were still able to work together for a common ideal, the ideal of Jewish nationalism that knows no barriers, that is broad enough and tolerant enough to include even two such opposite characters as Hess and Kalischer.
Strange as it may appear, it was Kalischer, the old-fashioned Rabbi, that proved the more practical of the two. While Hess’s work received but scant notice and was regarded by many of its reviewers as an impossible dream, as the chimera of an unbalanced mind, Kalischer’s audience was aroused by the fiery words and the impassioned appeal, supported as they were by authorities which they held sacred and binding. Although trained in organizing movements and experienced in directing and guiding large numbers of adherents, Hess accomplished very little in the realization of the new ideal which he espoused. His audience was not ready for it and the Jewish world either mistrusted him or entirely ignored him. Kalischer, on the other hand, had begun his agitation by personal appeal, by organizing societies among the people who had faith in him and who were actuated by the same emotions, but needed a mouthpiece to give expression to them, a guide to direct them. Neither the time nor the people were ready for such theories as were advanced in “Rom und Jerusalem.” It fell to a later generation to recognize the full value of that work and place it among the classics of modern Zionist literature. Kalischer’s arguments were in consonance with the spirit of the times and were couched in a form that appealed to most people of that age, although to-day the work is practically useless and to a great extent unknown.
Kalischer’s plan was practical although it was based on homiletics and
pilpul. His firm belief that the salvation of the Jews could come only through the. appearance of a Messiah, whom God would send to release them from exile, ‘was coupled with a conviction, as strong and as deep-seated, that the Jews themselves - must take the first steps toward their redemption.- In a letter to Anselm Mayer. Rothschild, dated 1836, ‘Kalischer ‘says: “Let no one imagine that the Messiah will appear suddenly and, amid miracles ana wonders, lead the Israelites to their ancient inheritance. The beginning of the redemption will be in a natural way, by the desire of the Jews to settle in Palestine and the willingness of the nations to help them in this work.” His idea was to make the recipients of the Halukah, who were then settled in Jerusalem, the pioneer colonists, In this plan, he secured the co-operation of many Rabbis, notably of Rabbi Elijah Guttmacher, who was one of his staunchest supporters all his life. In a fine Hebrew style, Kalischer advocated his idea in numerous articles in various periodicals and in many personal letters directed to Jewish leaders of thought and action of. the time. While he succeeded in attracting the attention of many, he was also strongly opposed by others who feared that the support given to the Halukah would suffer thereby. Kalischer, however, argued that when the rich supporters of the Halukah will see that the Jews of Palestine are not lazy but willing to work, if given the opportunity, they would be more ready with their support and the income of the Halukah would be increased, so that those who are not able to till the soil would have their accustomed assistance. These arguments, coupled with unremitting agitation, secured for his plan the interest of such men as Rothschild, Cremieux, Moses Montefiore and Heinrich Graetz and exerted a strong influence on Moses Hess. It was due directly to his exertions that the first agricultural school “Mikveh Israel” was established in Palestine in 1860, by the Alliance Israelite Universelle.
Kalischer’s greatest asset in the early struggle for his great ideal was his inexhaustible optimism. In spite of the opposition with which he met both on the side of the reformers and the ultra-orthodox, he never lost courage. Soon after the establishment of the agricultural school