The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 3 · March 1911
110printed page
scan 32 of 54
110
THE MACCABAEAN

sent, in a real sense, only those who elected them, that is, the pluralities, not of the citizens, but of a more or less smaller class, the voters—of artfully delimited districts. And these pluralities are more often than we like to think manipulated by a handful of men, a committee, or by a single man, a boss. Wheher this produces “government of the people, by the people, for the people” is no matter here. Pure democracy no one holds it to be. What I am at pains to bring out is the remarkable fact that in the present era, when pure democracy does not obtain within the States, it has arisen, for the first time in history, between the States. This is the epoch-making result of the Hague Conferences. It is a result still as unperceived of the general as it was un- looked for bv statesmen.

Let us see. At the first Conference in 1899, as was already noted, there were 26 States in attendance. At the second, in 1907, there were 44, nearly all the States in the world. At the third, which, in accordance with the "pious wish" embodied in the Final Acts of the second Conference, will probably be held in 1915 —thus insuring the permanence and regularity, at intervals of eight years, of this international assembly—we may look to see present, barring exceptional circumstances, all the States of the world. The principle, then, may be said to be established, that a State qua State, that is, any political unity recognized as a member of the family of nations, a person in the sense of international law, is entitled to a voice and vote at The Hague. Realize what this means. It means that not only the great Powers are present and make themselves heard; that goes without saying. It means that certain States you wouldn't call powers at all, and these, realize too, the greater number, are equally there and heard. To name but a few: Luxemburg, Montenegro, Siam, Persia, Servia, Bulgaria, Haiti, Ecuador, Cuba, Panama, Peru, the whole pot of the South American Republics. Let us recall that each State may send as many delegates as it pleases—174 are enumerated in the Final Act of the 1907 Conference, nearly double the number in 1899—each with the right to the floor in the plenary meetings of the Conference. In the several committees, respectively designed to consider special

topics and report thereon to the Conference as a whole, each State is also entitled to representatives, in each committee as many as it chooses.

Now, the most important fact of all is that each State has one vote, and only one. See how it works out. The island of Haiti is shared by two pocket republics, the Republic of Haiti and the Republic of Santo Domingo. The area of the former is 10,204 square miles (a little over that of Massachusetts) and its population, a year or two ago, 2,029,700, of whom nine-tenths are negroes, and the rest, save 200 Europeans, mulattoes. Of Santo Domingo the area is 18,045 square miles (a little over a third of New York State), with a population of only 610,000, a hollow toothful in New York City. On the other hand, the British Empire covers 11,407,294 square miles, one-fifth of the earth's surface, to say nothing of the British command of the seas, with a population of 396,204,752. At the Hague Conferences, the British Empire has one vote, the island of Haiti has two votes. Or again, take the Duchy of Luxemburg, with an area of 998 square miles (our tiny Rhode Island has all of 1,250), and a population, in 1900, of 236,543, one-third that of the City of Boston. Set against Luxemburg, the Russian Empire, with an area of 8,647,657 square miles, one-seventh of the land surface of the globe, and a population, in 1908, of 155,433,300. Well, at The Hague, the Russian Empire has one vote and the Duchy of Luxemburg has one vote. The United States has one vote; so has the Republic of Panama, one vote. So has our other creature, Cuba, one vote, so has every dear one of our Central and South American neighbors, one vote. Siam is equal to France, Bulgaria to Germany, Montenegro to Japan, every one to every other.

The Final Acts of the Conferences are in the form of conventions, declarations, resolutions, and Voeux (pious wishes). The conventions and declarations are signed by the plenipotentials of the several States, generally ad referendum, that is, subject to the ratification of their respective governments. When ratified they have the binding force of treaties. Since all or most States are thus made parties to the same treaties (though a