The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 3 · March 1911
105printed page
scan 27 of 54
THE MACCABAEAN
105

cal circumstances is against the permanence of territorial nationalities. The cosmopolitan world which preceded our present territorial nationalities was of longer duration that our present political onganization promises to be and of longer duration, also, than was the world of religious nationalities which preceded it. The old world of religious nationalities and the cosmopolitan world which followed it both fell because the impurity in religion corrupted life. If the basis of conflicting material interests is temporary what is the permanent basis of nationality? With Capital and Labor both internationalized, the means of communication cheapened, the rapidity of communication increased, —all sure promises of the future—What is to distinguish nation from nation? If material interests will not do it, what will? Shall we have an undifferentiated cosmopolitan jelly-world? We know that East is East and West is West. But this broad distinction is not a final one. The intermingling of races is too frequent and too constant a factor in history to allow of the supposition that racial distinctions are so deep seated as to be permanent. Humanity’s unity of origin is against the supposition. But even if a Mendelist believes it could be maintained that racial bases promise some permanence, they give nothing to strive for. Race would then maintain itself. Yet it cannot be denied that to live is to strive and to strive is to achieve. What can race achieve? This very question contains its own answer.

One of the new sciences which the last century gave to the world was the science of Volker-psychologie, showing how even as individuals ere endowed with varying psychical characteristics, so are groups of individuals too. Mazzini was wrong whe: he considered that rivers and mountains could provide a permanent basis for pational dist'nctions. The groupings of peoples after the Reformation began naturally along the 1865 of nature indeed. Not along the lines of external physical nature, however, but along the lines 1 iiternal psychical nature. Then the Jew would have come to his own. But the world was not yet ready for this grand result of evolution. The realms. of knowledge were not yet rich enoveh and religious consciousness was not yet deep enough to provide the psychically indi-

vidual groups of mankind with the activities on which individuality must feed. Material interests engaged them and the theories of Mazzini, as interpreted by Bismarck, won the day. But look around and see. Whereby do peoples stand more distinguished from one another now? By material, by physical or by psychical interests. Material interests as means of distinction dwindle more and more and as they dwindle so physical and_ psychical distinctions become more prominent, and the physical differences, both geographical and racial, so far as they exist, are but means to the grand resultant, evolution’s end, the psychical groupings of mankind. The souls of peoples also are immortal. Their souls will survive their bodies, and Wolf may well have declared when sailings against Montcalm and rowing to scale the Heights of Abraham, that he had rather have been the author of Gray’s Elegy than the Conqueror of Quebec.

The popular instinct is right when it regards jingo patriotism as the taskmaster enslaving mankind. The Jewish popular instinct 15 right when it refuses to see in Territorialism a final solution of the Jewish Question. And the Jewish popular instinct is right which refuses to see in the Jewish resettlement of Palestine the final fulfilment of prophecy, the last reward for centuries of patient suffering and the «rand result of Jewish history. Nay, the prophecy of history points far beyond this. The Jewish people, the one surviving religious nationality, which has survived as such despite itself, has been pointing to the truth in its spirit of prophecy, before Reason discoverea the way to the truth. The nationalities of the future will be religious nationalities. The soul and not the land will proclaim the man. East is East and West is West, Latin is Latin and Teuton is Teuton and Semite is Semite. Race and clime help to mould the soul. Races will intermarry and people will move, but differences of great groups will declare theniselves in differences of psychical ex-presston and no conflict of material interests will hinder the fulness and freedom of expression. The greater the race the more individual the expression. If it be asked how the individuality of psychical &roups of mankind expresses itself then I would ask in turn, what are the Jewish