In this second phase of any movement, therefore, we are confronted with a species of reasoning, substantially, as follows:
eee me een nn OO OO EE NOE = NEE ES Granting that Zionism is more advantageous to the Jewish people, that it is a worthy, noble and practical ideal; that, objectively considered, it is the only solution of a great problem, then the question is for me, the individual, to determine, subjectively, whether I ought to build my life with Zionism as the cardinal feature, As a “citizen of the world”—granting all that can be deduced in favor of Zionism— I may have other interests, and be moved by other ideals. I may be a scholar, scorning all but my books; a merchant who reduces everything to dollars and cents— and it may not pay to be a Zionist. I may be even a true idealist who yearns to move; who cannot be a stagnant observer like the book-slave scholar, or a piece of driftwood on the sea of time, flowing with the current, like the typical merchant, and yet my ideals may carry me far from Zionism. Finding myself in America, I might conclude that the noblest task before me would be to do my humble share in perfecting the greatest experiment in Democracy the world has yet seen. Lincoln, instead of Herzl, may be my ideal; Karl Marx, instead of Max Nordau, may appeal to me most.
An ideal movement like Zionism cannot hope to bring under its banner, as effective recruits, the passive spectator of events or the mere money-changer. Such men are very important factors in the preservation of civilization (as a static power), but they take very little part (as a dynamic force) in the progressive advancement of mankind. But, if the movement 15 to suceed, we must enlist the idealist among our people, who flock in such large numbers to other ideals.
To do this Zionism can no longer remain purely a political ideal. Our Zeitgeist that beautiful German idiom that expresses so much is Social Reform. Young, energetic souls yearning for ideals are responding to the Zeitgeist by dedicating their lives to the work of social regeneration. This does not mean necessarily the theories of the radical socialist the spirit of our Age is best illustrated in the concluding words of the famous speech of David Lloyd George in introducing the Land Budget in the English Parliament. Referring to the possibility of abolishing poverty, he looks forward with
the utmost confidence to that happy time when poverty shall have dissappeared from his beloved island, even as the wolves, that infested her highways in days gone by, can no longer molest our English.
no longer molest the English. The spirit of our age has brought forth Joseph Fels to work for the realization of the theories of Henry George. But why stray so far for examples of the Zeitgeist when Zionism itself, with its National Fund for a Jewish national land, is, thereby. a movement of social reform? The theories of our comrade in arms, Franz Oppenheimer, for co-operative farming in Palestine, is the introduction to the newer and higher Zionism: in short, to attract the young blood. that will bring success to our movement, we must respond whole-hearted to the Zeitgeist by converting political Zionism into social Zionism.
But what is Social Zionism? It means the substitution for the political ideal of autonomy, or political. independence, of that far more important social ideal of Bherty—the ideal of a Jewish people in Palestine so protected by commercial concessions that it can develop in the “Holy Land” a social-moral community - of Judeans on the basis of a better industrial system. Social Zionism would change our methods from political endeavors for securing a paper charter to cconomte efforts tor obtaining commercial concessions “legally secured and publicly assured” for the development of Palestine.*
Assuming, therefore, the establishment of such a Jewish Commonwealth, it would be unprofitable, at the present day, to portray in detail such a non-existent community, yet we may be able, nevertheless, to indicate some of its salient features. First, we must remember that such a community cannot be made, but is born. We have heard a great deal of the science of Eugenics —the science that aims at the improvement of mankind through proper and careful breeding —and it is a matter
*In an article appearing in the October, 1910, number of THE MACCABAEAN, entitled "A Social Commonwealth in Zion," the present writer endeavors to prove that such a contract granting commercial concessions, free from any charge of political manipulations, would probably be welcomed by the Ottoman Empire, and would prove beneficial to Jews and Turks alike.
