The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 3 · March 1911
80printed page
scan 2 of 54

the Talmud and Rabbinic literature, recognized as an authority on questions of Jewish law and practice and kept constantly busy in replying to such questions that were directed to him from various lands, he also found time for philosophic speculation along the lines of Jewish theology and wrote several works on these subjects. While he occupied the position of acting Rabbi in Thorn, Prussia, for more than forty years, and employed his rare gifts of organization in the development of the communal institutions of that town, he absolutely refused to accept any renumeration for his labors. This was not because he was a wealthy man. On the contrary, he had but a meagre income from a small business which his wife carried on and passed all his life in most moderate circumstances. So adverse was he to receiving any benefit from his public services that he insisted upon contributing his share to the communal treasury like any other inhabitant of the town, and even returned a gift with which the community presented him on the occasion of the marriage of one of his daughters. Nor did he ever accept any payment from individuals who had litigations before him. If they insisted upon giving him money, he would accept it for the great cause to which his life was devoted, the rehabilitation of Palestine, and had the names of the donors entered upon the book which he always kept open and ready in his office. From his scanty income he contributed largely to charity and his house was an asylum for many a poor traveler who was certain of finding there immediate assistance as well as sound advice. His absolute unconcern of his personal matters and his entire devotion to the services of his brethren, specially those of Palestine, made him beloved and respected by thousands and opened for him the doors of the most wealthy and most powerful of his time.

Although born in a small town in Posen and brought up under the guidance of such Rabbinic authorities as Rabbi Jacob of Lissa and Rabbi Akiba Eger of Posen, his mind was never narrow. Of course, he was all his life a truly pious Jew, careful about the smallest minutiae of religious ceremonies and observances and influenced by the manner of thought and reasoning prevalent in the Yeshibah. The bulk of his writings deal with Rabbinic legal subjects,

especially with the civil law as contained in the Hoshen Mishpat, on which he wrote an extensive commentary. But his versatility of interest was first shown in his philosophic work, Emunah Yesharah, in which he shows a familiarity not only with medieval Jewish philosophy, but also with the more modern productions along these lines, as well as with Christian philosophic thought. Later, it was evinced by his labors for the colonization of Palestine and his articles written on that subject. His views regarding the Messiah, the final redemption, the reintroduction of sacrifices and many other subjects that were regarded vital in the Jewish religion, were so novel and so modern that it took much rabbinic learning and extensive use of the method of dialectics to convince the Rabbis of his time of the orthodoxy of his position.

It was in 1862 that two unpretentious volumes appeared, advocating the colonization of Palestine by Jews. Moses Hess’s “Rom und Jerusalem” and Hirsch Kalischer’s Drishat- Zion,” both of which were published in the same year, and advocated the same ideal. But how different were the processes! The pious Rabbi, the skilled dialectician, the keen casuist and the liberal social reformer, the radical philosopher, the political iconoclast, each from his own point of view, holding fast to his own theories and beliefs, united in arriving at the same conclusions. Hess and Kalischer had absolutely nothing in common, except the inextinguishable love for their people and the yearning for its redemption. By philosophical reasoning, by logical argumentation, based on ethnic psychology and corroborated by ‘historic facts, Hess reduces the ideals of Jewish nationality almost to an exact scientific truth, with the enevitable truth, with the inevitable corollary of the resettlement of the Jews in Palestine, where this nationality can have a normal and natural development. Appealing to the emotions of religion and patriotism, of mercy and charity, supported by scriptural passages and Rabbinic utterances, Kalischer establishes the same thesis and arrives at the same conclusions. It probably never occurred to Kalischer that it was necessary for kim to prove that the Jews were a nation and that this nationality can never be destroyed, to the proof of which Hess is constrained to devote so much space. To him and to the public that he was ad-