to correct this childish error. To him who has tested the hollowness of much that boasts itself progressive, to him, with his wider outlook over past history and over the contemporaneous life, progress cannot mean mere doctrinnaire universalism; progress, to him, means, in the last line, genuine spiritual unfoldment, a deepening as well as an expansion, an accentuation of God-given individuality as well as a sympathetic approach to one's brothers of other races and faiths.
No Zionist could ever propose anything so absurd as a "blending of Americanism with Judaism"; we are not compounding teas or whiskeys, as we permit our practices, not our convictions, to be affected by the pressure of an environment. It is not a question of intermingling, uniting or otherwise joining two different civilizations, philosophies or faiths; much of what is extolled as Americanism is nothing more, by the testimony of history itself, than actualized Judaism; much else is simply a European teaching transplanted into a favorable soil. It is the cringing misrepresentation that would vindicate to Americanism every originality and make of Judaism a polychrome of every culture, it is this repulsive species of philosophical lackeyism that is bent upon raising all that is American upon a pedestal of hysterical panegyrics.
The Zionist is needed in Reform ranks to protest against this caricature as not answering in the least to the facts of history. The word Oriental appeals to his reverence: it designates the cradle of his infancy, the battlefield of his noblest triumphs; it appeals to his loyalty and his
pride, to his every hope and dream. He must refuse to join in the noisy acclaim which hails our age and our country as, respectively, the millenium and the paradise of Judaism; he sees religious desulation where the idolater of occidentalism brivzs of his monumental temples; he observes steady, unhindered growth of prejudice and intolerance, where the worshipper of “up-to-date” is exulting over empty phrases and ineffective resolutions: and, above all else, he preserves a warm fellow-feeling for those bonds of Jewishness, for those great underlying truths and aspirations, promptings and _ traits which make the Jew kin the world over, no matter how varied may be his garb or manner. his lanvunage or his customs.
The time is coming when the undienified absurdity, the unmanly cringing, the cold, immature conceit of this particular school of Reform Judaism will be patent to every eye. These are the soothsayers of an upstart generation: they please the vulgarity of the successful classes by hurning the incense of praise to the mob of one’s customers: by making Judaism small and Americanism great: by renouncing, with wunction, every clinging trace of Orientalism: by extolling the brand of Judaism they preach above every other variety that exists or ever has existed.
Our advancing spiritual refinement is bound, in the course of time, to free us from this infantile disease: but of all living voices Zionism, with its brave facing of the situation, its honest interpretation of our history, its fearless manhood, is best fitted to free American Judaism from this incubus.