The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 3 · March 1911
93printed page
scan 15 of 54
THE MACCABAEAN
93

come of spending any part of it in Russia. But apart from this it was all humdrum. The routine was so perfect that there was a journalist — not myself — with the programs in his pocket could write lengthy reports, speeches and all of their proceedings, without even going near them, and nnne wac the wicer

Then came Zionism. I owe the movement a grudge. It threw me out of my professional and logical rut. I love the movement because it found Jewish expression for me. It was a revolution and that was why it was objected to. It was a Coxey’s army to the ruling powers in Jewry. Who had given us the right to say anything? I remember Lord Swaythling saying to me very seriously one day. "[ don’t like the seven stars in Herzl’s design of a shield.” On the edge of a letter I find a note that a great man had en- quired “to what club does Herzl belong?” Rudolf Mosse of the Berliner Tageblatt hired Dr. Emil Reich, who died the other day, to attack Zionism, having decided to spend so many thousands of marks 0 kill Zionism. He was convinced that it could be done. When two of the great Jewish-German bankers were told that they could get the Jewish state for nothing,— they were negotiating for the funding of the Turkish debt,—they replied they would have nothing to do with such a Jewish scheme. Whereon the poor Zionist machine had to set itself full tilt against the money barons to prevent their getting a favorable hearing in Constantinople. It succeeded, one of its real diplomatic victories at the time. But you see it was the upstart character of Zionism that made it so objectionable. I think the movement began to do things. I actually believe it did something up to the third congress. Then everybody began to unload his pet theory of the Jewish need at it and the poor your cause was swamped.

I recall the Christmas week of 1899 which I spent in Vienna. I came at Herzl's request to discuss an issue of great moment. The Actions Committee was in session all that day and far into the night. It could not get to the matter in hand without throwing the routine business over, and every member had a portfolio full of business. We met again the next day, and the next. At length, the business was interrupted, and tired men discussed an impor-

tant project. In reality they did not discuss, they shelved it. And they were eager to act but as Kremenetsky, the only member of that committee now alive, said to me half apologetically, "What can I do, I am a month behind with my National Fund reports."

reports. So my earlier prophecy that unless Zionism hewed close to the line, that it would get lost in the same mazes that all Jewish movements, the I. C. A., the Alliance Israelite, have been lost, has been fulfilled to the grim letter. It is coming, it has become an educational movement, in a sense the most stupendous fallacy the Jews were ever guilty of since they were never as much in need of knowing as of the ability of doing. Let him, however, who is the people’s keeper rail against these things. If you think the salvation of the Jews can be accomplished by school systems, or artificial culture, all I can say is you have the right to think so. And all I want to say is that is just what your parents have believed for centuries, that is what the Yeshiba and the Beth Hamedrash meant in Europe, that is what the Lehmann, the Alliance and the Rothchild schools meant in Jerusalem,and well— looking over twenty years of conscious observation, I cannot find accomplishment.

And that is what ] was really coming to. The twenty years I pass 50 hastily in review have ended in dulling the edge 0] sensation—Anti-Semitism is no longer so violent. Dreyfus may even be rewarded by a public funeral in Paris. Arnold While is being argued with in England, Austria offers us nothing more dramatic thar Hilsner languishing in jail on a trumped up blood accusation, and cases of child. stealing in Galicia. Rusisa is moribund and Roumania has grown used to its misery. This dulling of the senses of the watcher is a loss. We have lost another counter in the game of life.

These twenty years have cost us our sexual purity. 1 don’t need. statistics. Twenty years ago I would have gone out of my way to see a Jewess who had made herself a plaything of the streets. and now I have to go out of my way not to see such. Despair in Russia and Galicia, and the coming full jolt against modern economic conditions have, together with irreligion, the spread of the gospel ease, and the teachings of the venal crew,