is suggested, all is poetically affecting. Thus he patiently etches for us Absalom's grave or the fountain near Jaffa, the Dead Sea or Jerusalem from the Mount of Olives, Petach Tikwah or Ekron, the mummy of Rameses the Second or some ruin of the Crusades. No Jewish painter has given so complete and so Jewish and so artistic an account of the Holy Land as Struck.
His views on art among modern Jews are decided. He is not content to de- nominate as “Jewish art” all that is produced by Jews. To be Jewish art, he says, a picture produced by a Jewish painter must show qualities only possible to a Jewish soul: in other words, the expression “Jewish art” can only be applied to pictures which have been painted by a Jew in such a way as to show forth the emotions and passions of his own people and his own life in the midst of Jewry. Jewish scenes, Jewish historical paintings, and the like do not deserve as such to be called Jewish. They must show that they have been inspired by the Jewish consciousness, by a Jewish soul. According to Struck the masterpiece of Jewish art in this sense is the celebrated picture “Ben Ami,” or as it is called in Dutch, “De Zoon von het oude Volk” (The Son of the Ancient People”), by the illustrious master Josef Israels, undoubtedly one ot the greatest painters of the century. This depicts an old Jew on the threshold of an old clo’es shop. One sees musty garments, faded metal lamps, and a hundred other second-hand articles. The subject is therefore a very simple one; there is no pose, no sentimentality. And nevertheless the sad eyes of .the old dealer gazing off into the distance personify, as his whole physiognomy does. all the pains and sorrows, the utter resignation of the Jewish people through all the centuries; and one can justly assert of this picture. says Struck, that a non-Jewish painter could never have painted it. A non-Jewish painter would have found it impossible to express so much Jewish feeling, so thoroughly is this picture filled with the Jewish spirit. Whenever the spirit of the milieu overcomes this Jewish spirit the artist ceases to be a Jewish artist. This is only too often the outcome, as witness for example the case of Max Liebermann, one of the most celebrated
of contemporary German painters, But in Israels and in Hirzenberg the Dutch influence, though undeniably present, has not been mighty enough to overcome the Jewish influence. Struck of course takes great pride in those other Jewish painters, even though they fail to work along entirely Jewish lines; and he calls an astonishing roll of Jewish artists who have climbed or who are slowly climbing to eminence. He names Ernest Josefsohn in Sweden, the unappreciated pioneer of the secessionist movement in that country, whose works are now highly prized; Camille Pissad, Francois Rafaeli, Levi Dhur- ner, and the sculptor Block in France; the sculptors Antokolski, Ahronsohn, and Bernstamm, and the painter Pasternak in Russia: Isador Kaufmann, |Jehuda Epstein, and Leopold Horowitz in Austria, and the talented young artist of Galicia, Abraham Neumann; Liebermann, Alexander and Ernest Appler, Pottner, Max Fab- ian, Jacob Plessner. and Max Levi among many in Germany: and Henryk Glitzen- stein, the Pole, who now lives in Rome. Nor does he fail to emphasize Samuel Hertzenberg, of the Bezalel school, who has been already mentioned. In England is the historical painter Soloman J. Solomons. And in America Loeb—was.
The mention of the name Josef Israels recalls another thread that binds Struck to Jewry. It was not accidental that Struck, after studying at the Berlin Academy and after having worked at painting with Max Koner and at etching with Hans Meyer, should have gone to Holland and made a thorough study of Israels' methods. He became a firm friend of the famous Dutch painter, whom he visits frequently. The etching of Struck's which has been commercially most successful— he obtained for the plate a fabulous sum— is a rendering of a landscape of Israels'. Israels has had altogether a beneficent influence upon Struck. Originally a member of the secessionist movement in German painting and at present a leader in the Berlin section of this movement, Struck has most probably been preserved through the influence of the Dutch painter from the extremes of this faction. His work, in color or in black and white, shows none of the puerile mannerisms of the worst examples of the secessionists: he inflicts no glaring contrasts of garish colors, his