friends told me that Sir Samuel had told him that I had bullied him into helping the Zionists. Had it been so the end would have justified the means. But the fact was not so. Montagu had yielded but a single point. He had no mind to loan or to give money for a charter. He never grasped the idea of the state. It meant to him nothing but colonisation and I still recall his closing words, the last time I ever saw him: "You have persuaded me to do this, that I am willing to stretch a point in favor of Palestine. Bring me some workable concessions, and I think we could finance the higher risk of unstable Turkey at a point lower in the market."
I had done my share, and left any further negotiations to be taken up by others, for I was preparing for what was to be an American trip, and proved a permanent settlement.
I hope that none shall read in this brief story of the Swaythling attitude any bitterness or rancour. For I myself have grown milder in age. I have come to understand the wandering in the desert. Wandering forty years across a strip that could be covered in three days. A generation had to die and another come to maturity under new conditions before the invasion of Palestine was possible. Chevra builders are not state makers. Even Herzl had
few supporters who understood the value of the state idea. The majority lapsed back to the colonization idea, and the culture idea, and every idea native to them and their upbringing, just as whenever Moses left the camp the Children of Israel lapsed back into the old idolatries. There is a safe anchorage in the old idea that made the golden calf possible at the foot of Sinai, and in our times we merely change the names of our ideas as suits the mode, but not the idea itself. Hence reversion to old attitude is so easy that the change is imperceptible. The generation that believes that Judaism is nothing but a multiplication of chevras, synagogues and lodges, and religious classes, an immense Partingtonian broom, that can keep assimilation and destruction away, must go its way. A new generation must be born, a generation that experiencing the stress of its political life will understand state building as a natural course, just as natural as starting a lodge to-day. And some times when I muse over these things I imagine that the future of Israel belongs to some young westerner, who seeing a state and all its political consciousness grow up around him as a natural force, will find it within the strength of his brain and his hands to do the same natural thing for his own people, in their own land.