The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 2 · February 1911
42printed page
scan 2 of 40
Facsimile · scan 2 of 40
Scan of p. 42
Text · transcribed from the scan

Rothschild singlehanded, fought the Lord and a timid community, and always won, He took the scars of battle in fine style. I remember the Jewish World once called him the “old Obadiah.” He was just as friendly the day after. Just by himself he took the crowd of Russian balebattim, the presidents of so many dozen hole and corner chevras, men who knew little English, men who understood fight better than union, men whose language he did not known, and made a federation of them, and built them model synagogues. It is not true that any man might do this who was willing to pay, for they questioned his motives for years, and they lost much individual koved in the transaction. I believe he did more for the preservation of the peculiar kind of anglo-orthodoxy than anyone else, and was perhaps the only constructive orthodox worker of his time. Fate would have it that he ‘must be so “froom,” and Theodor Herzl so “link.” For Swaythling when he was still plain Montagu was something of a Chovevi Zionist. He with Joseph Sebag Montefiore were the administrators of the Moses Montefiore property in Jerusalem and its conversion provided a balance which went to the Chovevi Zion, which earmarked it for the Bnai Jehudah colony which it was bent on creating, and of which our friend Goldman, of St. Louis, became the administrator. I believe that even for a time he was treasurer of the Chovevi Zion, but if so, it was a mere incident.

It was in 1891 or 1892 that Montagu aided by Rabbi Simeon Singer called the first great mass meeting of the Jews in London, and set them dreaming wildly of the return to Zion. He swept the Chovevi Zion to one side. It was always willing to be pushed aside when there was a risk ahead. At that meeting he invited thousands to sign a petition to Lord Rothschild, who as prince of the captivity was to press Lord Salisbury to instruct the British “Ambassador in Constantinople to negotiate with the Sultan for a settlemen of Jews in Palestine so large that it would operate to relieve the Jews in Russia whose misery called forth this action on the part of Montagu. I listened that night to Montagu and to Singer, and to

the tumult of applause, and the vision of every man of sitting under his own fig tree, the prophetic picture was part of the petition, was very clear to me. Lord Rothschild, so I learnt, blue pencilled that reference to himself as prince of the captivity, and the plan that Montagu drew up for the settlement never saw daylight until I published it in THE MACCABAEAN. in 1903.

In the summer of 1896 Herzl came, for the second time, to London, and some one arranged a lunch between him, Montagu, Hermann Landau, who always had been a pro-colonizer of some kind, and the late Col. Goldsmid who might be regarded as looking after nationalist interests with caution. Unfortunately for Jewish history Theodor Herzl penned a postal of acceptance on Saturday; he did it with sangfroid, the date was there. Besides he was not the man to deny his indifference to the Shulchan Aruch. That Sabbath written postal was fatal. Three or four days afterwards I entered the Montagu office, and was welcome enough up to the point of wanting the Member of Parliament for Whitechapel to preside at the first Herzl meeting to be held in the East End, the meeting that made Herzl famous in Jewry. No sir, he was not wanting in sympathy or admiration of the man, but—it was a long terrible but— Herzl had written him on the Sabbath, and could Zion be properly served by a Jew who did that? No, sir.

Even Cicero would have wasted his eloquence. And learning that Montagu held off, Landau did likewise. As for Goldsmid, he countermanded the meeting as being convened by a tent of the Chovevi Zion, and so we assembled, with the message before us, resolved ourselves into something else, and went our own way and convened that meeting. And such is fate, the refusal of Montagu brought Gaster into the movement. He was made the chairman, and did it right well, at that time.

The great polemical period followed. We Zionists said things, and Montagu became bitter, and he came out against the movement. Whereon I pursued him with the deadly parrallel of his own speeches