have been given by either of the contracting parties"
Independently of these express provisions admitting of the cessation of treaty relations between the two countries, it is a recognized doctrine of international law that, under conditions precisely like those which have been described, the abrogation of a treaty, even though it contains no provision for its termination, is justifiable.
The article of the treaty of 1832 which has been violated by Russia is the one which was the main object of that treaty —the clause which was given precedence over all others, the very basis and foundation on which all other provisions contained in the document rest. It is not necessary, therefore, to resort to fine distinctions or to indulge in close analysis for the purpose of ascertaining whether the test laid down in this and other authorities has been met. The situation which has been broken is not only material to the main object but was and is the main object of the treaty.
But it may be argued that the suspension of commercial relations between the two countries may hurt our trade. I have a higher opinion of the American people than to believe that they are so destitute of idealism, so devoid of a sense of honor, as to regard a matter of this supreme importance with the eyes and the soul of mere shopkeepers. However extensive our trade with Russia might be, we could well afford to jeopardize it, rather than have it said that our country rates the dollar higher than it does the man: that it esteems the volume of its trade more than its National dignity.
After a'l, the entire trade of the United States with Russia does not much exceed $18,000,000 per annum, What is that to a nation the products of whose 50 during the past year amount to nearly nine billions of dollars? Should we then lose ali of this commerce, our material prosperity would not be perceptibly affected.
It may also be said that Russia is about to engaze in Jarge undertakings which will enlist American capital, the development of mines, the construction of store houses for grain, the building of railroads, and that we are imperiling such enterprises by denouncing our existing treaties with
Russia. But what of that? Is it not better that we may know in advance what the attitude of Russia is to 06 toward American citizens, before they invest their capital for the development of the resources of Russia, than to lodge complaints after the capital has been invested, and promises have been broken? And after all there are still opportunities in the United States for the profitable employment of adequate capital for the promotion of our own industries, and Central and South America still offer promising fields for the investor.
There are others who will prate of the historic friendship of Russia for America, and the tale will be retold of what Russia did for us during the Revolutonary War, and during the Civil War. That fable has been thoroughly analyzed, and the real facts have been demonstrated. But assuming that in the past we may have profited from Russia’s attitude, who is so credulous as to believe that the land of the Czars, the country of absolutism, has been so enamored of freedom, of constitutional government, of democracy or of republicanism, as to have acted cither from love of us, or of our institutions ? Whenever Russia has acted, it has been simply and solely from political expediency.
But let us assume that Russia has, from any motive whatsoever, extended to us offices of friendship. Have we not fully requited all of its kindnesses? Was it not through the intervention of President Roosevelt that Russia was extricated from one of the bloodiest and most disastrous war known to history? The account between the two countries has been fully balanced so far as political favors are concerned.
But there still remains a long account against Russia of broken promises, of violated obligations, of a compact condemned and disregarded, of dishonor inflicted upon our country and its citizens, and unless the virtue of manhood has deserted this Republic, its citizens will no longer patiently witness the mockery of diplomatic procedure, but will insist on a complete abrogation of every treaty now existing between the United States and Russia.
