The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 2 · February 1911
61printed page
scan 21 of 40
Facsimile · scan 21 of 40
Scan of p. 61
Text · transcribed from the scan

practice has continued ever since, and not only Russian Consuls, but Russian Ambassadors have refused to vise passports after ascertaining, as a result of inquiry, that the bearer, though an American citizen, is also a Jew.

The Russian Government has thus broken its compact, flouted its obligations, and ignored a series of continued protests voiced by every President of the United States since the administration of President Hayes.

In the meantime the United States has sacredly observed the obligations of this treaty. Its highest court has at the instance of the Russian Government, enforced it most drastically and under conditions when, by strict construction, Russia might well have been denied that which it demanded as of right, under the terms of this very treaty, whose obligations it has thus deliberately disregarded. It will be instructive by way of contrast to consider the facts and the decision in Tucker vs. Alexandroff, (183 U. S. 424). Alexandroff was a conscript in the Russian naval service. He was assigned to the duties of an assistant physician. In 1899 he was detailed with fifty-three others and man the cruiser Varing, then under construction by Cramp & Sons under a contract with the Russian Government. While the vessel was still under construction, and before its acceptance by the Russian Government, Alexandroff deserted, went to New York, where he renounced his allegiance to the Czar of Russia and declared his intention to become a citizen of the United States. At the instance of the Russian Vice Consul Alexandroff was arrested on the charge of desertion in accordance with the terms of Article IX, of the treaty of 1832. This provided that the Consuls, Vice-Consuls, and commercial agents of the two contracting parties “are authorized to require the assistance of the local authorities, for the search. arrest, detention, and imprisonment of the deserters from the ship of war and merchant vessels of their country. . . . Such deserters, when arrested, shall be placed at the disposal of the said Consuls, Vice-Consuls, or commercial agents, and may be confined in the public prisons, at the request and cost of those who shall claim them. in order to be detained until the time when they

shall be restored to the vessels to which they belonged, or sent back to their own country by a vessel of the same nation or any other vessel whatsoever."

It was contended on behalf of Alexandroff that when he arrived at Philadelphia the cruiser was not a ship, that at the time of his desertion she had not been accepted by the Russian Government, had neither equipment nor armament, had not received on board her crew nor had she been commissioned for active service, and was not therefore a ship of war

Notwithstanding the facts upon which stress was thus laid, the Supreme Court held that on a liberal interpretation of the treaty on Varing was a ship of war and Alexandroff, having been detailed to her service, was, from the time she became a ship, a part of her crew. Alexandroff was therefore surrendered to the Russian Government without a quibble, without an effort to do violence to the language of the treaty, without seeking to implant upon it exceptions which it did not contain, and in spite of the fact that, on the strict interpretation that would have been given to a criminal penal statute of our own country, he would doubtless be discharged.

The reason for this adjudication is to be found in the words of Mr. Justice Brown, which, when compared with the interpretation which Russia has given to the first article of this same treaty, emphasises the astonishment evoked in any well constituted mind at the wanton disregard by Russia of the sanctity of its national honor. Says the distinguished jurist, in terms that reflect credit upon our jurisprudence:

"We think, then, than the rights of the parties must be determined by the treaty, but that this particular convention being operative upon both powers and intended for their mutual protection, should be interpreted in a spirit of uberrima fides, and in a manner to carry out its manifest purpose. (Taylor on International Law, Section 383.) As treaties are solemn engagements entered into between independent nations for the common advancement of their interests and the interests of civilization, and as their main object is not only to avoid war and secure a lasting and perpetual peace, but to promote a friendly feeling between the people of