The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 2 · February 1911
50printed page
scan 10 of 40

is as gratuitous as it is unfounded. Not only have the President and several members of the Actions Committee studied the situation in Turkey by sojourning there for various periods, but the Zionist Administration has a responsible representative in Constantinople who has already been there more than two years. We have yet to learn when and how long Mr. Zangwill has also studied the situation on the spot. But the charge of ignorance is slight beside the assertion that Zionist teachings may be "only a delusion and a snare." It is difficult to understand how a movement which is dead can be capable of being "a delusion and a snare." Perhaps the real delusion is that of Mr. Zangwill—that Zionism is dead. But even if, according to his other account, it is a mere movement "for providing Jewish culture in the diaspora," we still fail to see how it can delude or ensnare, unless Mr. Zangwill means to suggest that it is not providing genuine Jewish culture. If the committee of "La Tribuna Libera" are free from the "Sephardic stupidity" which Mr. Zangwill attributes to the Ottoman Jews in general they will probably perceive the inconsistency of their adviser and ask him to be good enough to reconcile his statements.

But the most interesting feature in the whole article is the advice that the Ottoman Jews should cultivate an Ottoman Jewish Nationalism, Unfortunately Mr; Zangwill omits to explain what he means by this, so that the Ottoman Jews are not likely to receive mush enlightenment from him in their supposed perplexity. But an attempt must be made to solve the mystery. It is clear that even according to Mr. Zangwill Ottoman Jewish Nationalism is something wider than the Jewish religion, since he offers it as the common platform upon which both believing and unbelieving Jews can combine. The unbelieving Jew is therefore urged to espouse Ottoman-Jewish Nationalism. But as Mr. Zangwill admonishes him not to be turned into a Turk we must conclude that the term “Ottoman” simply indicates the locality in which Jewish Nationalism is to be fostered and does not in the least affect the essence of Jewish Nationalism. In other words, Jewish Nationalism is an

absolute conception independent of the country in which Jews may be living. But Mr. Zangwill in a previous passage characterises Jewish Nationalism as "hollow and phantasmal." Hence he advises the Ottoman Jews to pursue a phantom.

The fact is that Mr. Zangwill finds himself in a curious dilemma. On the one hand, in his bitterness at the failure of his own territorial schemes to solve the Jewish question, he now wishes to prove that such a thing as Jewish Nationalism is impossible. On the hand, he is opposed to the Turkish Empire becoming, like America, a melting pot of races and nationalities. Hence, while denying a universal Jewish Nationalism he fabricates the theory that the Ottoman Jews can only preserve a strictly local Jewish Nationalism. This may be a fine stroke of polemical legerdemain, but in the discussion of serious questions we must dispense with the juggler's arts. We agree that the Jews in Turkey should preserve their Jewish Nationalism, but we also maintain that the Jews in all other countries should do likewise and for a similar reason —so that they should not become an ingredient in the local melting pot. All these local manifestations of Jewish Nationalism however, are simply so many expressions of universal Jewish Nationalism, since we know of only one Jewish nation. Mr. Zangwill seems of the opinion—at least in his latest article—that outside Turkey only the Jews in Austria can retain their Nationalism, as there is a co-existence of different races. He has apparently forgotten that in a multitude of other countries, including America, which he regards as the classic type of racial melting pot, there are stalwart bands of Jewish nationalists. As for Austria there are countless Jews there who will not recognize the Jewish Nationality and who group themselves with Germans, Poles, Czechs, or what not, even against the interests of the Jewish Nationality. There is, however, a Jewish National Party in the country, who zealously safeguard the national interests of their people. But they do not foster "Austrian-Jewish Nationalism." They are not an isolated body, cut off from their fellow-Jews in all other parts of the world. On the contrary, they realize that