The new immigration is very largely one of individuals, a considerable proportion of whom have apparently no intention of permanently changing their residence, their only purpose in coming to America being to temporarily take advantage of the greater wages paid for industrial labor in this country. . . ."
This means, as interpreted by Mr. James Bryce in the new edition of his "American Commonwealth," three things: First, "Whereas they [the old immigrants] started at once for the land and set themselves to fell the woods or till the prairies of the West, the bulk of the later comers have either, like the Jews and Greeks, flocked into the cities and taken to the life of retail trading or of handicrafts and petty industries there, or have, like the Slovaks and Poles and Italians, found occupation in the mining districts or in the railway construction and other forms of unskilled work." Second: "Whereas the early immigrants, Irish, Germans, Scandinavians, usually applied for and obtained citizenship very soon after their arrival," "a certain part of this recent immigration is transitory; Italians and Slovaks, for instance, after they have by chrift accumulated a sum which is large for them, return to their native villages;" and "between those of the new immigrants who work in mines or in the construction of public works and the native American there is very little contact and practically no admixture. Even in the cities the Italians and the Jews keep to themselves, often occupying poor quarters exclusively their own." Third: "The American people of the future will be an amalgam from a much greater number of component elements than have entered into it theretofore. Moreover, these new accessions, except the Jews, Greeks, some of the Romanians, the Finns, and the Armenians, belong almost wholly to the Roman Church, so that if the children of the immigrants remain connected with that Church, its share of the population will be relatively greater." What is vastly more important, the ethical standard of the recent immigrants under which they live make the maintenance of any high standard very difficult. "It is difficult for parents who must themselves toil all day long to retain any control over children who enjoy the license and are exposed to the
temptations of a vast city. Accordingly, the percentage of juvenile crime among the children of the foreign born is more than twice as great as it is among the children of native white parents."
We believe that the above summary of facts will suffice our present purpose, which is to put before our readers certain fundamental principles which we believe should govern the country in its future regulation and restriction of immigration.
I. This land belongs to its citizens. But the present generation have in it only a life estate. They are solemnly bound to leave it unimpaired to their children and their children's children. This involves guarding, not only against needless waste of its material resources, but even more against adulteration and corruption of its citizenship. We have come to a policy of restriction and regulation of immigration none too soon. This country is not a Hospital for the diseased, nor an Asylum for the feeble-minded, nor a County Farm for the world's paupers, nor a Reform School for the morally deficient.
Nor is there any adequate reason why it should any longer be a Refuge for the oppressed of other lands. In western Europe there is not now any such political oppression as drove out refugees from Ireland and Germany and Italy in the first half of the nineteenth century. In every country of western Europe the theory is entertained, as in America, that governments exist for the benefit of the governed, and life and property are as well safeguarded as in America, in many countries better safeguarded. There is no such wholesale violation of liberty as obliges us to open our doors to all exiles. Metternich and King Bomba have left no successors. The Armenian is relatively safe even in Turkey. It is only in Russia that military despotism still rules: it is only the Russian Jew that needs a Refuge. And it is not our duty, nor even our right, to allow our whole international policy to be determined by sympathy for him.
II. The need of this country is not for cheap labor. The wealth of a country consists not in its money-bags but in its men. Too much cheap labor means too many multi-millianaires; we have an excess of both already. National progress and material wealth are not synonymous. . . . What we want in America is men who
