The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 1 · January 1911
259printed page
scan 29 of 42

argument is thus. He sees no chance of maintaining the Jewish people in existence except by means of persecution. He believes that the day of persecution for our people is nearing its end, and that with freedom and toleration we shall intermarry wholesale, having neglected every vestige of our faith and our religion in order to take our part in the citizenship of the nations among whom we are cast. With our faith and religion neglected and rejected, within comparatively the next few years the Jew will become merged, lost, as a genus will be extinct as is the megatherium and the dodo.

The soil in which alone, the Jew qua Jew, can thrive is persecution, argues Dr. Fishberg. That soil is fast drying up. Hence, the destiny of the Jew is rapid disappearance in the near future. His book thus tends first to besmirch our past and then to damn our future! What a paradox is its message! All these long and toilsome years we have been hit and buffetted, without even deserving punishment, for being a separate race—the direst offence that we thought had any basis of justice in its allegation! And now, those who are fired with the spirit of care and regard for the Jewish people and its future, who slave and toil for the amelioration of their people’s lot, are really its worst enemies, for they are working so that the condition in which alone the Jew can thrive as Jew, but cannot endure as man, shall be replaced by one in which he is utterly doomed as Jew but may thrive as man. Thus, we poor Jews are fast on the sharpest horns of a dilemma the world has ever known—persecution or damnation are our only alternatives. So Dr. Fishberg would have us believe. That is the bewildering paradox of his book. But—

I wonder how often, in the course of cur history, there have been Fishbergs who thus have “prophesied” concerning us? Here, in this very week, we are anniversaUsing a period in our history when all that was distinctly Jewish in our people had well-nigh petered-out like the drop of 570601 oil that remained for the Temple. But some of the oil was left—it served tr render our light still perpetual. Juden rerans. We have survived that cry uttered with the raucous voice of violence. We stall assuredly not be utterly demolished when it is blown at us through Dr. Fishherg’s statistic-trumpet. He is right when

he points to Jewish defection, to intermarriage, to conversion, to careless disregard of all that is Jewish amongst our people in lands where they are free. But he forgets that the Jew these thousands of years has never ventured to pray for the salvation of the whole of his people. It is for “the remnant of Thy flock” that he invokes mercy. It is on the remnant that he relies. It is the remnant by which Judaism has ever been saved in its darkest hours. The Maccabæan remnant saved it from Grecian assimilation, earlier the poor remnant of the Jews in Babylon who “sowed in tears” reformed our people in Palestine. Earlier still, the remnant of Gibeon saved us from annihilation. The faithful few are sufficient—the glorious remnant who are “for the Lord.”

And so, as I close this volume of Dr. Fishberg’s after carefully reading all he has to say about the origin of our people, the important thing after al] seems to me to be that we are. If we are not a race, if we are not a nation, if we are not a religious community, we are anyhow a “nexus,” Jew joined to Jew the world over. I believe that the “nexus’—call it what you like—would not have existed. as we know it to have existed, all these centuries, and would not have influenced humanity as it has, except it performed a great service in the economy of things. I 60 not believe that exactly now when that service is so greatly needed “to break down all idols”’—religious, social and economic, which abound on all hands—it is to “dribble down the sandy delta” and become lost in the sea of time. I profoundly dis-. trust his purview of our destiny. 1 believe the remnant—the glorious remnant— will come from some quarter, will assert itself, will remain true and do its work.

Science, statistics, study and all the olagies applied to the Jew are impressive perhaps. But, those who know—in the widest and most comprehensive sense ot the word—who know our people will, through all the din of long words and learned terms, midst all the mist of argument and contention, hear within their souls the still small voice of ages. Clearly, quietly, yet surely, it will breathe to them words which will quickly dispel the mist and calm the din—‘He, watching over Israel, slumbers not nor sleeps!” It requires a lot of statistics to overcome that!