the world, he finds, reveals Jews of differing sizes, complexions, color, with differing head-sizes and the like, and this leads Dr. Fishberg to deny our unity of origin. "Individuals or groups of individuals," he declares, "may change their language, their religion; may forget their most sacred traditions within one or two generations. But there is no known way of changing the complexion, the head-form, the height and the like and to assure their transmission to the progeny in the new shape." This sweeping statement he modifies a few sentences further on and admits that the psychic, moral and intellectual capacities, the height and the muscular system of an individual may be modified by environment. "But these factors," he states positively, "are impotent to transform a dark-haired individual into a blonde or a round-headed person into a long-headed one."
It is a pity that the author before making this pronouncement, and sticking to it, did not call and consult the nearest hatter. That useful, albeit non-scientific, individual, if at all observant, would have told Dr. Fishberg that the average size and shape of people's heads —those belonging to the same people or nation —are constantly changing. He could have been told that in the same family among brothers there are frequently the brachycephalic and the dolichocephalic. Nay, further, it not seldom happens that the shape of an individual's head so changes as to become transformed from being on the long side to being on the round. It has been noted that change of occupation persisted in has a tendency to change the shape of the head, and it is undoubted that certain avocations are almost invariably to be found with certain shapes of cranium. Is it not similar with the color of the hair? In how many families is not the difference between brothers and sisters, some with dark hair and some with light, noticeable? How often has it been observed that a pale-complexioned light-haired child will be born to parents of quite contrary characteristics and with no known ancestor to be made accountable? I profoundly disagree from Dr. Fishberg in his arbitrary conclusion which he lays down as a law. I do not upon the strength of my knowledge of anthropology nor because I am learned in morph-
ology, or, for the matter of that, in any other ology. But I oppose ordinary common observation, undimmed by statistics and not blinded by an obvious desire to prove a certain thesis, to all he says upon this point. He has given a far too despotic value to his statistics and to the so-called laws of heredity which he adumbrates, and not nearly enough consideration to environment, which some of our best scientists now declare to be a far more potent factor in determining somatic conditions than does heredity.
For granting all our author has to advance as to these very clear differences of physical characteristics subsisting between Jew and Jew—and no one denies them— we have the patent fact that a set of people scattered throughout the world are known wherever they are found and are differentiated as Jews. What is the nexus which joins them? Dr. Fishberg says it is not race. Is it religion? Clearly the variations in that department are as great as on the physical side. He would have it that there is no more than a look, a something on the faces of all sorts of Jews, which denotes them; but that this is not the result of a common origin but of a common world-fate. A coachman, he instances, has a certain facial form, a mien, a bearing which instancely marks him out, though you may have fat and thin ones, long-headed and short-headed ones, fair and dark coachmen. But if this is the whole of the secret of the likeness of Jew to Jew, how comes it that they retain it in generations that know not the Ghetto or its suffering, on whom the hand of persecution has never fallen? It is difficult to follow Dr. Fishberg in his conclusions as to our origin.
When, however, we approach his ideas in the destiny of the Jew, the short reasoning of the author becomes even more apparent. Dr. Fishberg dismisses the destiny of the Jews very summarily. He merely puts a literary megaphone to his mouth, and shouts Juden heraus! "Only that and nothing more." It is a new way of an old cry with which, alas! the Jew is familiar. That, put shortly, is the author's message as to our future. For he perceives nothing but a constant increase amongst us of intermarriage and of conversion, a constantly growing proportion of Jews as Jews going to perdition. His
