The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 1 · January 1911
256printed page
scan 26 of 42
Facsimile · scan 26 of 42
Scan of p. 256
Text · transcribed from the scan

itself to giving advice and seeking a territory which is as yet unnamed, Mr. Zangwill could with propriety assert that it is a dead movement. The hesped of Zionism will be spoken when it become like the territorial organization: A movement with only a President, who is capable only of writing "interesting" reading matter.

THE UNION OF AMERICAN HEBREW CONGREGATIONS.

ALTHOUGH the 22nd Council 01+ the Union devoted a great deal of its time to the question of immigration, the keynote of the convention was sounded by Dr. Kaufman Kohler, president of the Hebrew Union College, who grasped the opportunity once more, with a trifle less vehemence and passion, to expound his theory of reformed Judaism, and to utter a timely word on immigration matters. We confess that it is difficult to follow his line of argument. While his Judaism stands foi faithfulness, it also stands for freedom of thought and progress and liberalism. Judaism will refuse to be Orientalized, for it is “a world task, a power working for righteousness, individual and = social, and to spiritualize all of life and the whole of humanity.” To unravel this tangle we refer it to theological experts. This great religious power is to emanate from American Judaism, and thus it follows that Dr. Kohler pictured America as the land of the future, “the land of promise for all the persecuted.” But is it not a fact that great statesmen and leaders in Jewry were invited to speak before the Convention on immigration because it is apparent to all who are cognizant of the facts that America is about to refuse to consider itself responsible for the further maintenance of “a land of promise for all the persecuted ?” Does Dr. Kohler actually believe that America is the land of the future for all the Jews?

The imminence of action on the part of

the United States favorable to restriction, has, it seems, paralyzed the reasoning faculties of those Jews who have stood so bravely for Americanism. These are erev restriction days in America, the curtain is about to fall on the first act of the drama, and it is probable that the players in the next act will speak differently, coming to their senses during the intermission.

Dr. Kohler certainly did not help the cause of free immigration by deriding orientalism in Judaism. If Orientalism is such a breaboo, then there are good grounds for the exclusion of its exponents. A Russian or Roumanian Jew does not shed his former habits and modes of thought when he passes through Comimissioner Williams’ hands. As a matter of policy, Dr. Kohler should have insisted that what he calls criental traits are not unworthy of consideration, that it was from the oriental Jew that religion came into this world, that the oriental Jew has in him qualities which can be eminently useful in the amalgam of races out of which the future American is to emerge. But to have said this would have meant for Dr. Kohler a repudiation of his own past. He would have been compelled to set about readjusting his theology to this new argument, and to undertake such a task would have been impossible for the venerable president of the Hebrew Union Colleve.

JEWISH NATIONAL FUND BUREAU FOR AMERICA.

All Zionists of Greater New York whose boxes were not collected from for the last six months are requested to please send their names and addresses in to the Jewish National Fund Bureau for America, 165 East Broadway, in order that the National Fund box collector should be sent to their homes.

We also ask those Zionists who have National Fund boxes and have changed their place of residence lately to please send us their new address.