EDITORIAL PAGES
THE JEWISH MISSION.
DR. MAX HELLER, who is at the same time an ardent Zionist and president of the Central Conference of American Rabbis, gives new interpretation to the much-abused Jewish mission, with which Zionists will agree without condition or qualification. THE MACCABAEAN has urged objections to the reformed idea of the mission which are re-stated with greater force by Dr. Heller. We have opposed the Jewish mission theory because it was not a product of Jewish life, receiving its inspiration and value from a short-sighted desire to justify the political emancipation of the Jews in the German Empire. It was born out of political necessity, perhaps, but it had no place in any religious organization. It was a mission without missionaries. It was never intended that there should be any missionaries. As a bit of legal or political fiction, it served the purpose of the assimilationists to give them an opportunity to declare that there was some rationale to their existence, whereas there was none. The mission itself was preparatory to assimilation.
There is a Jewish mission, and every Zionist believes in it. It is the thought of that mission which gives ideality to our movement. It is our belief that the Jewish people, settled on their own soil, free from the deteriorating effects of hostile envir- oments, will be able to produce a form of social life, of religious life, of all the var- ‘ations of human aspirations, that will serve asa great force in the civilization of the future. It was the Jewish people who brought a pure religious ideal into ths world. It may be the destiny of the Jewish people of the future—we believe it is 50 to be their destiny—to contribute some thing more to the progress of humanity by developing their own national individuality. Already we see in Palestine the germs of future social forms that will bud into institutions modeled on principles that are
bound to illuminate by their example the development of social ideals in the outer world. And as our movement progresses, with Zionists remaining true to themselves and to the Jewish past, there will be innumerable instances of the influence of Jewish thought and life upon civilization.
MR. ZANGWILL'S ADVICE.
Mr. ZANGWILL’S advice to the Ottoman Jews makes “interesting reading,” and while that 1s not to be considered a criticism, it characterizes Mr. Zangwill. He is at all times interesting, and suffers probably because of the fluency with which he expresses his ideas, and his adroitness in reasoning himself into or out of any position he may desire to take on any question. One feels that he could just as well argue for the other side if he were so minded.
Dr. Levin has effectively replied to his “advice.” Dealing with an abstract proposition like that of finding a territory for the Jewish people may require the talent of a geographer, but does not entitle one to speak with authority on practical matters. Had Mr. Zangwill grappled with the problem of an actual settlement of any territory he may have acquired, then his views on Zionism and its problems would have had some value. Zionism to-day is in the process of being realized. The movement has created a tendency in the direction of Palestine which is inspired by Jewish nationalist ideals. There are many problems that will have to be settled. Every day the organization, weak as it is in material forces, faces issues that have a practical bearing on vital issues. To say of such a movement that has set out to acquire the territory it considers its ultmate goal that it has not fully acquired it, is begging the question. If nothing were being done, and the organization devoted