The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 1 · January 1911
232printed page
scan 2 of 42

the soul of Israel having survived the body as the Jewish commonwealth went down in ruin; we know, reasoning by facts rather than phrases, that Judaism was preserved by that life of separateness which furnished bonds of outward and inward community as strong as any political or geographical ties: we know that the true diaspora, the real Goluth has begun to-day, when it is being sought, in vain, to hold the spirit of Judaism without a body of Jewish life and Jewish custom to house it; we recognize the real dispersion of to-day in the disintegrating influences of Christian atmosphere, material struggle, of snobbery and dissension; nor can we any further delude ourselves as to the persistence of prejudice, the tenacity of entrenched dogma, the remoteness of millennial conditions, whether among nations or individuals, in political, social or commercial life.

For all these reasons the old-fogy Reformer will always clash with the Zionist so long as he founds his theory of a mission upon the exploded notion that dispersion has been a blessing and means an opportunity, a notion that climbed its dizzy apex of perversity in the unseconded proposal to regard the Ninth of Ab as a day of thanksgiving, to turn the memory of the world’s deepest tragedy into rejoicing, a proposal that will always stand out as the unconscious self-satirizing of a hollow theory that lacked all breath of life. Dispersion, certainly, has been providential in its planning and educational in its aim; in God's inscrutable plan we may yet need a century or two of such schooling to prepare us adequately for our long career in the land of our fathers; but that our dispersion has been worth its cost through such religious influence as we either have exerted while dispersed or are likely to exercise in further and more actual dispersion. will not be maintained by any man who refuses to exaggerate our active work in the world’s religious unfoldment for the past nineteen centuries or our importance as a paramount factor in the world’s religious advancement of to-day.

To conclude, so far as the negative attitude of the Zionist towards the mission-idea of the Reformer is concerned: if the “Mission of Judaism” means this: that. living among our neighbors, we have a

God-appointed opportunity, a historic task of teaching them the truth of the one God; if it means that we have been preserved for all these ages, have been tried and are being tried by all the banes of homelessness, discrimination and alienage that we might the better preach to our neighbors this fundamental religious verity, if it pretends that this is the conviction and the practice, the guiding principle and aspiration of Reform rabbis and their congregants, that it is the rationale of Israel's existence in the Dark Ages and now: then the Zionist, whether Reformer or Orthodox, standing as he does by the realities of the Jewish life, must repudiate any such theory as a self-delusion, as a harmful and demoralizing pretence. Pale abstractions like these can not be the life-blood of a people; our lives, our ambitions and enthusiasms know nothing of them.

Has, then, Judaism and the Jew no mission whatever? Is Zionism, then, no more than an attempt to preserve the race from extinction or even, still less, to remove it from everlasting friction to some measure Of peace and unfoldment? If political Zionism stood for no more than political regeneration or geographical concentration, if it were a movement that addressed itself only to the humanitarian sympathies of the world and to the physical needs of the Jew, it could never have aroused the enthusiasm or exercised the rejuvenating influence that it has created. Zionism does look, in the first place, to the physical basis of the legally safeguarded home and derives hence its appeal even to the Jewish anarchist or atheist, to the Jew that has lost his Judaism, to the Jew who must revert to the Jewish soil, to a Jewish atmosphere, in order to find his true self again. As yet Zionism is a mere yearning for home, for the peace that does not mean inactivity or silence, but which promises consistency, independence and a future. Zionism, therefore, is many things to many men: it holds out Shulchan Aruch orthodoxy to one and agnosticism to another; socialism to one and the single tax to another: a farm-— ing patriarchalism to one and a manu-— facturing beehive to another.

To myself, Zionism signifies the mission of Judaism, the translation of the monotheistic idea into social righteousness, the