The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 1 · January 1911
244printed page
scan 14 of 42

ses six million Turks, about two million Greeks, an equal number of Armenians and Bulgarians, and about ten millions Arabs. Even between the Turks and the Arabs there are no close relations, and of a fusion of the various national groups there can be no talk. And here, one pertinent fact may be pointed out; it was not out of pity or other exalted feelings that the Congress of the Young Turks recently held in Salonica,' decided that they did not wish to accomplish the unification of all the different national groups, and on the contrary desired to encourage different national developments, with the condition that they make one common cause of the defense of the Ottoman Empire. The Empire is therefore Ottoman and not Turkish, even though it is now in control of Young Turks. We demand of Mr. Zangwill that he look more closely at what is now. actually transpiring.

It was ten years ago. One of the Zionists prominent at that time appeared before a select gathering of Jews and non-Jews and delivered a lecture on the resources of Palestine. He spoke in a masterly manner and showed what great possibilities were latent in that land and pointed out what great benefits could be bestowed upon the

Jews by allowing them to freely settle in Palestine in particular and in Turkey generally. Beautiful pictures were then presented by the speaker and reaching the climax of his oration he exclaimed with the prophet: Is there no balm in Gilead?

That speaker was Israel Zangwill.

Snce then ten years have elapsed. In the interval Mr. Zangwill has not seen Palestine. He has occupied himself with Uganda and Territorialism and with other matters of the practical application of "The Melting-Pot" theory, and then the "Dreamer" began to speak of Palestine with ridicule and contempt. Now he sends a message to the Turkish Jews to warn them against the Zionist peril.

Every man has the right to change his opinions and his conceptions of the world, but why should Palestine suffer? The land has remained the same, with the same hidden resources and the same balm in Gilead. It is harder to build up the smallest structure than to destroy the largest one. All that we can wish is that fate may be kind to the Territorialists and bless them with the acquisition of at least a little bit of a country and that they may have the opportunity to test the strength of their leader not in destroying but in creating.