The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 1 · January 1911
242printed page
scan 12 of 42
242
THE MACCABAEAN

up a community like that which is now to be found in Palestine; the new settlement would have to go through all the trials and tribulations of pioneering, at least as severe as those experienced in Argentine,—and then it would be seen that even outside of Palestine it is necessary to make sacrifices in order to put a hew community on its feet. Then the Territorialist would soon have to confess that an acquired autonomy is of no value, that every autonomy must grow up of itself, that the entire proposition of a ready-made country with its own Government machinery is a Utopia, or, worse, like the old idea of Homunculus, or, as the Jewish Kabbalists regarded it, a matter of witchcraft. But God was good to Zangwill, and he still hugs the bare, abstract idea. To be sure. he is deprived of the joys of building, but to make up for th's he is free from pains of the bearing of children, and he therefore takes time. now and then. to taunt his opponents.

In yet another respect must one record the infelicity of Mr. Zangwill's love first for real Zionism and then for Zionism in its nakedness, or, as they have named it, "Territorialism." And this befell not only Mr. Zangwill, but also other Zionists who had played important roles in the movement. In the ordinary course of life, it often happens that a young man falls deeply in love with a maiden, loves her with all the fire of his soul, and yet fears to marry her, and when he does marry her, love vanishes as if it fled at the very altar. It is subsequently realized that the young man was more in love with loving than with the girl; that he loved the process of loving, the desire to unite his life with the life of another; that he loved—if one may so express it—the theory of love, the abstract conception which always remains pure, has nothing in common with the littlenesses of life, is far removed from all sordid moments, and encounters no hindrances.

And so it happens that so long as one plays with the idea of love, all goes well, but as soon as one comes in contract with the reality, the idea loses its glamour, for the idea is ever soaring heavenward, while the reallity has to do with both the heavens and the earth. The reality must have a sound foundation, without which it is not reality. It is this foundation of reality

which is feared by Mr. Zangwill, even as it is feared by all who are in love with an abstract idea.

Mr. Zangwill points out as an example Dr. Kohan-Bernstein, who was always one of the most devoted of Zionists, who labored for his ideal with his whole heart and soul, and who yet felt so unhappy in Palestine that he had to leave that country. He did not have anything to do there as a Zionist, and had to return to the exile, and not only that, but to settle in a city, the mention of whose name makes us tremble and arouses fear and hatred within us—Kishineff. Indeed, this seems to be a riddle, and appears to be a bad omen for the success of the entire settlement. But the explanation which Mr. Zangwill gives of this riddle is fundamentally false. The fault lies not with Palestine, nor with the conditions under which the work is being carried on there, but with Dr. Kohan-Bernstein himself. For proof, there can be stated the fact that after Dr. Kohan-Bernstein had left the country, a hundred other persons of the intelligent classes settled there, and not of them is complaining; on the contrary, they have found a good field for the exercise of their labor and activities. Among them are physicians, architects, engineers, teachers, merchants and promoters and workers in general. They have all found places in their chosen vocations, and are satisfied with the new life. Had Dr. Kohan-Bernstein been satisfied with his professional work as a physician, he would have done very well in Palestine, at any rate not worse than in Kishineff. But he is a political Zionist and seeks political activities. He wishes to gitate, to exercise influence in public life, and here begins the tragedy of unfortunate love.

In the exile, in the Goluth, one can deliver beautiful speeches about the love of the Jew for the land of Israel, one can become burningly eloquent about, for instance, the promotion of the Hebrew language, but in Palestine such speeches and perporations lose their value, especially when one must deliver then in the Russian language. Palestine is the touchstone, and it is soon shown who are really yearning for the new life in order to help in shaping the reality, and who are merely in love with the sacred ideal. For the lat-