The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 1 · January 1911
240printed page
scan 10 of 42
Facsimile · scan 10 of 42
Scan of p. 240
Text · transcribed from the scan

instinct, and even the Zionist minority in which the dormant spirit of independence began to stir has not yet recovered its touch with political realities. Indeed, Zionism has now almost entirely transformed itself and instead of signifying a political exodus from the diaspora into a Jewish territory—as the poor Russian Jews dreamed who put up Herzl’s picture in their cottages—it now signifies a mere movement for providing Jewish culture in the diaspora itself, with a faint concession to the old Zionism in the shape of a centre of this culture in Palestine, such as a University in Jerusalem. Nothing could be more antithetical to the Herzlian Zionism. Even Chovevi Zionism which Herzl came to overthrow was really more akin to his own. The wheel which was set rolling at such vast labor has come full circle. To us Jews of Western Europe thus witnessing the breakdown of the Herzlian or Territorial Zionism, it is pathetically amusing to see you Ottoman Jews distracted and embarrassed by a movement which is already dead, or only alive in circles that are outside Palestine and have every intention of remaining so. But how can 1 wonder you are taken in! The popularity of Zionism in Russia increases in exact proportions to its impossibility. and now that all danger of t's realization is over, the most respectable elements of the German Jewry grow sympathetic and sentimental.

"Zionism then—by dint of its impotency to fulfil itself—has imperceptibly transformed itself into Nationalism, the third and last of the theories we have to consider: the theory that the Jews, even without territorial preponderance anywhere and even without the nexus of Judaism, can yet by virtue of a special culture, form a national unity, of which you Ottoman Jews are part. But this conception is hollow and phantasmic, far more indeed than Zionism. The impossibility of Zionism is a mere historic accident. The impossibility of Nationalism lies in its own immer nature. The Jews of the world have indeed a large measure of race-affinity due to the practical coincidence of race and religion, but they differ widely according to their environment, even when they have retained Judaism, and with the subsidence of Judaism these differences would be accentuated to breaking-point. There

is nothing, indeed, in race that can long counteract the pressure or attraction of universally differing environments and mutually alien patriotisms, unless the race be exposed to a contemptuous isolation like the black race in the Southern States of America. Though there are signs of such contempt for the Jews here or there, it is not universal, nor can a people well place its hopes in the pariah’s pale or in the fiery ring of persecution. Without a common religion or territory, the Jews could not form a nationality, not even though they had a common language, and a common culture. Indeed, the very idea of a Jewish language or culture in the diaspora is a topsy-turvy notion, since a common culture and language are the natural fruits of a common life, and cannot artificially give rise to a common life, unless at the price of perpetual ossification. For a time Jewish nationalists may continue to sing the songs of Zion in many a strange land, and persecution in these lands and the amateur and absentee effort to realize their dretam in Palestine may keep them together. But Nationalism is not like religion, a fabric that can resist time and defeat, and soon a gencration will arise that knows not Joseph. For the Turkish Jews therefore to throw themselves into a non-territorial inter-Jewish Nationalism would be to pursue a road leading nowhither.”

Mr. Zangwill concludes that a united Ottoman Jewry should take the path of Judaeo—Ottoman nationalism. But khis is possible only in countries where the federative policy of preserving a variety of races under one government is recognized That is, in countries that preserve their races side by side, as in an intricate pattern, in a mosaic. He criticises the Young Turks for favoring the melting pot policy. The Young Turks have forgotten, he declares, that melting pots are not to be made in a day but are a result of historic and psychological conditions.

“Any attempt to enforce homogeneity would in fact precipitate Armageddon and shatter the Ottoman Empire. Such being the simple realities of the situation it is far from impossible—indeed the reopening of the Albanian schools points distinctly to the possibility—that the Austrian ideal of Federation will sooner or later oust the vistonary American ideal, in which event