“ And it is here that I come to that non-existing Melting Pot. I think the term an unfortunate one. We use one in my newspaper office. And II have noticed that in order to smelt successfully all the alloys must yield to heat at about the same temperature, otherw.se the ingots tlıat are cast are poor in quality, coarse and full of holes. In every smelting there is always a £ollection of dross that floats to the surface and has to be removed like scum, whilst a certain residue remains at the bottom of the crucible. I think if Mr. Zangwill had watched the process he would not have so described the United States. You and I with our differing experiences do not yield at the same temperature. We cannot make an alloy of equal parts, and knowing this, feeling this, we will not approach the crucible In plainer words I am not tempted to merge into you, and I do not blame you if you do not wish to merge into me. Neither of us I take it are eager to bring up our children so that they will destroy the inheritance of culture, experience and faith we bequeath to them.
Or to go to the melt'ng pot again. What is the dross that can be removed to get a clear alloy? Are we all to denude ourselves of our inherited tendencies, character, history and tradition, so that we shall emerge from the crucible not mixed but just so many physical creatures all in the likeness of each other, all with the same vague mental make up. Is this acceptable to you? And jwould: it be good? I think not. I believe we all like ourselves too well, our self-love is too great, to eschew ourselves in this fashion. And if we did it would not be well. America has not succeeded so wonderfully because of a composite brain. American success rather is the result of the strivirgs of so many highly individualized brains having the utmost of free play.
Where would we be without the distinct efforts of the English, and the Scotch and the Irish and the German in this land? Each one has left a distinct mark upon what we call American civilization, and that mark was made by the
ego of race consciousness. On the contrary I claim that we need each other as we are. We are not a flat unified people. We are at least four worlds within these states, and if we want to dream into the future let us dream of the confederation of the races, not their individual destruction. And keeping within the narrower sphere of the position of the Jews let me say that in my judgment the world would stand to lose a great deal, with small chance of gaining anything, by that emasculation and evisceration which the Melting Pot theory implies. Eugenics is merely a theory, it is not yet a science. This is my one stand-pattism. In the matter of humanity its various shadings, its physique and mentality, let us hold by what we have. We know to what progress it has brought us, and we really know nothing of a hybridized world.
May I not therefore close with this thought: Let us put away from ourselves the thought of one people swallowing the other. But instead of letting this old world of ours, old in its sentiments and prejudices and conceptions, jog along at the old stumbling gait, let us see whether we cannot remove a few of the prejudices that bar her proper progress. The Jew is the minority. Christianity is the majority.
Do you think it presumptuous of one of the minority to ask for a little less of tolerance and a little more of equality. It would help make this America more like the America of our dreams.
Why not let us agree to disagree on matters in which agreement is unnatural, and why not agree to approach a little nearer to actual neighborliness? We do not ask for the payment of the debt which it is admitted you owe us. We merely suggest that you approach us in a neighborly spirit. We breathe the same air and in the end will return to the same dust. Why split life on a dislike of people, customs and traditions you do not know, why not think, when you meet us, in the spirit of the religious truth we share in common; we are all the children of one Father, one God made us all!
