The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 6 · December 1910
196printed page
scan 6 of 50
196
THE MACCABAEAN

highest, you must not look for religious agreement except in fundamentals, among the Jews. The three representative religious attitudes, reform, conservatism and orthodoxy, represent more than the attitude of three classes, or of three generations of Americanization.

Having shown you that the Jew is to complex to permit of serious generalization, I take the risk of dealing with him in some generic terms. He was the first white man to set foot on this continent, he drew the maps of the ocean, financed the expedition, and even Columbus according to the latest authorities, had a Jewish strain in his blood.

In that sense American Jew might be made meaningful. Having been the first American he disappeared from the scene .and came here by permission of the Dutch, and has been here ever since. He was tolerated to the extent of undertaking to support his own poor and he has done so. He did not, however, become a factor until the forties of the last century, ‚and really began to be spoken about since the immigration of the last 30 years tended to bring him in numbers over the million mark. Since then he assumed that portentous phase of a “problem.”

He has given to this land his natural patriotism. I say natural patriotism, for the Jew is the patriot par excellence. As a critic of my own people I do not always admire this patriotice passion which possesses them. In Russia they champion the cause of Russia, in Germany they love Germany, and in Austria they love Austria, whereas I believe that affection should be for cause shown or for affection returned. Jews have 'fought in every ‚American war, which is perhaps the least quality of patriotism, the more earnest abiding form being their pride in being able to say, “I am an American citizen” in the same spirit that the Roman citizen said, “I am a Roman citizen.” They have brought their trading and business ability here. They have made New York the commercial center it is, and if they were permitted I think they would make Wash- ıngzton Street a counterpart of Broadway in the next decade.

Their intellectuality will be made to count in the next 20 years of American history unless their efforts are repulsed.

I venture to say that if President Lowell were asked he would say that his pessimistic views as to the student’s interest in scholarship does not apply to the Jewish undergraduates.. On the contrary Prof. Muensterburg complained a few years ago, in my hearing, that the Jewish students go in too much for psychology when they should be taking to athletics as a way of letting off sunplus steam. Prof. Eliot said something of the same sort, and as the Jews are very sensitive to criticism they went pell mell into athletics, and during the last few months too young Tewish boxers have died in this eitv.

In brief the Jews gives the United States patriotism of the warmest kind, and brains, when the individual possesses them, that have been sharpened by three thousand years of experience. The United States gives him in return freedom of movement, the value of which he understands, liberty of conscience, and the citizen’s privileges. Might one not stop right here and say these things which are the natural complement to each other in a well ordered world, balance each other? That which the Jew brings and that which he receives make the American Jew at his best and at its worst, allowing always for the idiosyncrasies of the individual which may be a mere matter of the way in which he pronounces the letter “a,” or may be a distinct and peculiar view of lite and what he can get or make out of it, or a mere Jliking for certain dishes, etc.

But the issue does not stop right there. The theoretical Jew seems to be right welcome everywhere. He is in every Christian home, in the Bible, and he is in every Christian mind as the romantie reminder of the ancient days, the man who had his being when history began, and who is still here with the halo of the stern unbending East upon his brows. That living creature, who sometimes forgets this halo, finds himself the victim of a peculiar problem, and the belief that this problem will end itself in a certain way has caused one of our novelists, Israel Zangwill, to describe the United States as a Melting Pot, in which Jew and non-Jew will be melted down into one homogeneous unit.

What is the problem? Very often the Jewish problem reminds me of the gap in the