The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 6 · December 1910
194printed page
scan 4 of 50

women in our colleges and universities have an interestin all manner of questions; their plan of studies often resembles Joseph's coat of many colors. But how many of you think that a small part of your time so laboriously devoted to roaming over the whole world of science and of literature could and should be given to those things that are near\u2014and that might be dear\u2014to you? Even when you venture to visit the country itself as a globe-trotting tourist you have time and opportunity for a thousand and one sites, but hardly an hour to see places and institutions that are of particular Jewish interest.

Do you wonder, then, that efforts which are not backed and fostered by a healthy public sentiment, have proved in many cases abortive? You have left our pioneers out there to their own slender resources slender in money and in ideas. We hear a great deal about the divisions and dissensions and rivalries with which Palestine Judaism is rent; as if we ourselves lived as one happy family without a cloud in the sky. It is true, these divisions do exist. But whose the fault? What have we, who perhaps live in better circumstances, done to counteract them? Or, rather, how much have we not done to add to them? Even our great societies that have interested themselves in the work, have found it impossible to pull together. The Alliance in Paris, the Hilfsverein in Berlin, the Lemaan Zion in Frankfurt, and various lother organizations, pursue their aims not only without any juncture, but often tugging away at Jerusalem towards the different points of the compass. What example do the helpers show to those whom they profess to help? Half of the effort that is put forward is wasted because the effort is divided. We are endeavoring to pull a car with several ropes, each rope being dragged in a different direction.

To pull together, however, means that we shall first have formulated some plan upon which to base our work in Palestine. As you are aware—no such plan exists. "And every one doeth that which seemeth right in his own eyes," is the motto that we seem to have taken. Many and different plans for this work have been formulated on paper and the attempt has been made to carry some of them out. It is not my place to judge them. I would even go so far as to say that any one of several is as good as its neighbor; if only we would keep to it and carry it out to the end. We are continually digging up and filling in, digging up and filling in, so that all that remains is our own sense of having worked. Now there may be some "Zekhut" in this—for ourselves. But think how much greater this "Zekhut" would be if our labors brought the requisite fruit to those for whom we labor?

The three things, then, that we need most urgently are a renewed and an intenser interest in the concerns of Palestine; a more combined effort in translating that interest into effective results; and a definite plan for the road on which we are to go. Am I sanguine in hoping that we Jews who are Americans shall lead the way in introducing the needed reforms into Palestinian Jewish work? In America, we pride ourselves upon our power of organization. Our country has grown great in consequence of it, and powerful in the councils of the world. Is there then sufficient Americanism in American Jews to place them in the lead in this new work for Palestine? The interest that has been shown here for the Technical School at Haifa, and for the Experimental Station of Dr. Aaronson lends being to the hope that there is this Americanism in us, that we shall bring to the solution of these questions in the oldest country, some of the lessons that we have learned in the youngest.